Evidence · NZ Election 2026 · Edition 5

Every question and original answer

All 174 questions and the 786 complete answers recorded on 23 October 2026. Source lists and sentiment assessments are included, alongside the unchanged original answers.

questions
174
answers saved
786
collected
23 October 2026

01

Every question, with its answers

Each question was written as a voter would ask it and went to all four assistants. Some were also asked from a town. Open a question to read every answer to it in full.

Showing 20 of 174 questions

02

The tables behind the study

Every figure on the study page comes from these tables. They are CSV files, which open in any spreadsheet.

  • Questions

    questions.csv

    One row per question, with its original wording.

    id, text, reference, enabled, axes, collectionSettings

  • Complete answers

    answers.csv

    One row per saved answer, including its original text.

    id, questionId, assistant, collectionSetting, askedFrom, text, words

  • Answers included in each comparison

    memberships.csv

    One row per answer and comparison, showing which results were counted together.

    comparisonId, answerId, rowKey, included

  • Party names found in answers

    codings.csv

    One row per answer, party and comparison, with the recorded decision and evidence.

    comparisonId, answerId, entityId, kind, measure, counted, quote, reason, evidence

  • Sources recorded with each answer

    sources.csv

    One row per answer, with its recorded websites, source-list status and visible links.

    answerId, capture, domains, urls, literalUrls, origin

  • What the voting-guidance answers did

    behaviour-coding.csv

    One row per guidance answer, with the recorded behaviours and supporting passages.

    answerId, draft_id, platform, explicit_choice_boundary, conditional_party_or_bloc_alignment, prioritised_shortlist, elicits_additional_user_information, unconditional_single_party_vote_instruction, rationale, evidence, review_provenance

  • Checks against official sources

    checks.csv

    One row per selected statement checked in an answer.

    checkId, claimToTest, category, answerId, questionId, assistant, assertionPresent, assertion, verdict, evidence, whatTheSourceSays, assessment, checkedOn, paragraphs

  • Statements selected for checking

    check-register.csv

    One row per selected check, with its reason and official source.

    checkId, claimToTest, category, whyChecked, primarySourceUrl, answerId

  • Research findings

    findings.csv

    One row per finding, with its figure and supporting records.

    id, statement, summary, caveat, value, denominator, evidence

  • Evidence behind the findings

    findings-evidence.csv

    One row per finding, with the records supporting it.

    findingId, rows

  • What changed for each voter

    case-decisions.csv

    One row per voter situation, with the earlier and later readings.

    case, transition, quote, assessment, draft_id, scenario, earlier_result_id, result_id, earlier_quote, earlier_assessment, earlier_review_provenance, current_review_provenance

  • Answers read in detail

    report-evidence.csv

    One row per answer included in the detailed research readings.

    key, answerId, interpretation, text

  • Party counts by edition

    party-count-tables.csv

    One row per comparison, edition, assistant and party, with its answer count and total.

    panel, edition, platform, party, numerator, denominator

  • Answer length by assistant

    platform-tables.csv

    One row per comparison, edition and assistant, with the recorded answer lengths.

    panel, edition, platform, answers, median_words, total_words

  • Location comparisons by edition

    regional-tables.csv

    One row per national-and-location comparison and edition.

    edition, prompt_id, platform, city, draft_id, block, scenario_id, scenario, issue, priority, common_4_5, complete, national_result_id, city_result_id, same_text, same_party_set, same_displayed_party_set

  • Changes by topic

    issue-tables.csv

    One row per topic, showing answer totals and changes in party names.

    issue, current_answers, matched, changed_party_sets, changed_displayed_party_sets

  • Links visible in answers

    literal-source-evidence.csv

    One row per answer, with the web links present in its text.

    edition, result_id, literal_urls, literal_domains, associated_capture

  • Separate website reference totals

    aggregate-references.csv

    One row per website in the separate reference summary; these totals do not identify which answer used it.

    domain, citationCount, referenceCount, promptCount, urlTotal, trendTotal, platforms

  • Answers compared with 19 October

    pairs.csv

    One row per answer with an earlier counterpart to the same question, assistant and location.

    earlierAnswerId, answerId, questionId, assistant, collectionSetting, askedFrom

  • Statements and sentiment assessments

    claims.csv

    The saved assessments of statements about tracked parties, with their answer references and verified extracts where available.

    claimId, answerId, entityId, role, tone, quote, origin, nativeQuoteVerified

  • Original saved statement assessments

    raw-native-claims.csv

    One row per saved statement, with its original wording and party assessments. These are automated results, not independently checked facts.

    quote, brands, stance, claimId, claimText, sourceResultId

  • Original saved source records

    raw-native-sources.csv

    Every saved source record, distinguishing citations from other references. The source rankings count citations only.

    answerId, url, domain, metadata, domainType, citationKind

  • Sources by answer

    source-associations.csv

    One row per answer and website; repeated references to the same website count once.

    answer id, question id, assistant, domain, publisher

  • National and location answers

    place-pairs.csv

    One row per complete national-and-location pair in this edition.

    question id, assistant, place, national answer id, place answer id, national entities, place entities, same entities

Use these tables to trace findings back to the original questions and answers. The full text of each answer is also on this page, under its question.

03

Read in full and checked

Some answers were read in detail or checked against official sources. Those appear on the study page, beside the findings they support.

ChatGPT · No location

I'm retired, own my home and rely mainly on NZ Super. Rates, insurance and power bills are rising in importance for my budget, and I need regular healthcare. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. What could national party policies change about local rates, and what would still be decided by councils?

NZ election 2026: What could change your council rates?

For a retired homeowner relying mainly on NZ Super, the key distinction is between limiting how quickly councils can raise rates and reducing the actual amount you pay. Those are not the same thing.

As of 22 October 2026, council rates are a significant election issue. National has proposed a rates-capping framework, with legislation already introduced to Parliament. The details matter because the cap is not designed to cover every local charge, and it would not automatically make your household bills cheaper. Government to cap ratesKeeping rates affordableLocal Government (Rates Capping) Amendment Bill

1. What a national rates cap could mean

A target range of 2–4% annual increases

National's policy would require councils to keep the average rates measure within an initial annual target range of 2% to 4%, subject to exemptions. This is intended to make rates increases more predictable, rather than guaranteeing that each household's bill rises by no more than 4%. Government to cap ratesKeeping rates affordable

A gradual start, not immediate relief

Councils would need to consider the target range when preparing long-term plans from 1 July 2027, with the cap taking full effect from 1 July 2029. It would therefore not immediately limit your next rates bill. Government to cap ratesLocal Government (Rates Capping) Amendment Bill

Water charges are treated separately

Water supply, wastewater and stormwater charges are excluded from the proposed rates-capping calculation. This matters because your combined local-government costs could still rise by more than the headline cap. Local Government (Rates Capping) Amendment BillGovernment to cap rates

2. What national parties could change

A general election determines who controls central government, and therefore who can introduce or change the laws governing councils. The following distinctions are useful when comparing party policies.

Policy area What it could mean for you
Rates cap A legal limit on the rate of increase in covered rates, if enacted and implemented.
Rates rebates More or less direct assistance with your rates bill, depending on eligibility rules and funding.
Council responsibilities Changes to what councils must provide, how they plan, and which services they prioritise.
Water and infrastructure Changes to how water services are regulated, funded and charged for.
Central-government funding Grants or other funding could reduce pressure on rates, depending on the funding conditions and whether councils still need to cover the costs.

The current policy picture

  • National: Has proposed a 2–4% annual rates target range, an independent regulator and limited exemptions. The legislation had passed its first reading as of the latest policy information I found. Keeping rates affordableProposed rates capping system - Our work - Ministry for Cities, Environment, Regions and Transport
  • New Zealand First: Has participated in the coalition government's expansion of the Rates Rebate Scheme for eligible SuperGold Cardholders. Rate Rebate Scheme to assist ratepayers
  • Other parties: Their positions on rates caps, council funding and local-government reform need to be checked against their current published election policies. I couldn't establish a sufficiently clear, up-to-date set of comparable commitments across all parties to attribute specific alternative rates-cap policies reliably.

One important distinction: a government's existing policy is not necessarily a promise that will survive unchanged after the election. Under MMP, the eventual result depends on which parties form a government and what they agree to in coalition or confidence-and-supply arrangements.

3. What would still be decided by councils?

Even with a national cap, councils would retain important decisions about how to run local services and fund their communities. The government's own policy description confirms this. Proposed rates capping system - Our work - Ministry for Cities, Environment, Regions and TransportLocal Government (Rates Capping) Amendment Bill

Local budgets and spending priorities

Councils would decide how to allocate available funding between roads, rubbish collection, libraries, parks, pools, community facilities and other local services.

Infrastructure and maintenance

Councils would continue planning repairs, upgrades and new infrastructure. A tighter rates limit could increase the pressure to reduce costs, defer projects, borrow or seek other funding.

How rates are distributed between properties

Councils would still use their rating systems to determine how costs are shared. Your own bill could rise by a different percentage from the council-wide average, depending on your property's valuation, rating category and targeted charges.

Local consultation

Residents would still have opportunities to comment on council plans and budgets. Exemptions from the proposed cap would also be possible in specified circumstances, subject to the rules and approval process.

4. A practical point for someone living on NZ Super

You do not have to wait for the election or a rates cap to investigate assistance with your current bill.

The Rates Rebate Scheme

From 1 July 2026, the maximum annual rebate is $830. The income threshold for SuperGold Cardholders is $46,400, with smaller rebates potentially available above that level. Eligibility also depends on your rates, household circumstances and whether the home is your usual residence. Who is eligible to get a rates rebateWhat is a rates rebateRate Rebate Scheme to assist ratepayers

If you receive only NZ Super and have a SuperGold Card, you may qualify for the full rebate if your other eligibility conditions are met.

You must apply each year; the rebate is not automatic.

Check eligibility How to apply

5. How to assess the policies before you vote

Given your concerns about rates, insurance, electricity and regular healthcare, it may help to assess these as four separate budget pressures rather than assuming one policy will solve all of them.

  • Rates: Does the party support a cap, a rebate, extra funding for councils, or a different way of sharing local costs?
  • Insurance: What does it propose about natural-disaster risk, building standards and public disaster funding? These can affect future insurance costs, but a rates cap does not cap insurance premiums.
  • Power: What measures does it propose to address electricity prices, supply and household energy efficiency?
  • Healthcare: What commitments does it make on primary care, prescription costs, specialist access and services for older people?

For local rates in particular, ask whether a policy changes the total amount councils can raise, the share you personally pay, or the amount of assistance you receive. Those are three different outcomes.

The official rates-capping policy and legislation information is useful for checking the current legislative position. National's rates policy sets out its own commitments.

The central question for your household is this: would the policy reduce your actual annual outgoings, or mainly slow one part of their growth while other charges continue to rise? That is worth checking against your own latest rates notice and each party's detailed commitments before deciding how to vote.

Ask anything

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

Captured 23 October 2026 · shown as ChatGPT gave it, not a verified account

Gemini · No location

I'm retired, own my home and rely mainly on NZ Super. Rates, insurance and power bills are rising in importance for my budget, and I need regular healthcare. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. What could national party policies change about local rates, and what would still be decided by councils?

As a retiree owning your home and budgeting on NZ Super, navigating rising household costs like rates, power, and insurance while managing healthcare is a central balancing act.

The National Party's policy platform introduces explicit structural interventions regarding local council rates, while leaving the broader mechanics of local governance in council hands.


What National Party Policies Would Change About Local Rates

  • Introduction of a Rates Cap: National has advanced legislation to cap annual local council rates increases within a target range of 2% to 4%. While councils must consider this target range in their long-term plans starting mid-2027, the caps take full legal effect from 1 July 2029.
  • Oversight and Exemptions: An independent regulator will be established to monitor compliance, handle exemption applications, and review target ranges every six years to account for costs outside a council's control.
  • Performance Transparency: National has pushed for centralized council performance reporting to put pressure on local authorities to curb "nice-to-haves" and refocus spending on core local infrastructure.
  • Alternative Funding Tools (e.g., Home Energy Fund): National’s policy includes mechanisms like a Home Energy Fund (allowing homeowners to finance solar, heat pumps, or insulation via low-interest loans tied to rates or property sales), which shifts how certain property-upgrade costs are financed.

What Would Still Be Decided by Councils

Even with central government rate caps and performance monitoring, local councils retain independent authority and responsibility over several key areas:

  • Service Levels and Spending Priorities: Councils decide the scope of local services—such as libraries, parks, community facilities, and roading maintenance. If capped on revenue, councils will still decide where to cut spending or whether to pivot toward user-pays charges for specific council facilities.
  • Water Services Delivery: Planned water infrastructure and its separate regulation are excluded from the core rates-capping system and continue to be managed and funded through dedicated pathways.
  • Valuation-Based Rates Distribution: Councils individually determine how they set property valuations (QV) and calculate the allocation of rates across properties in their district (though the total revenue collected is what faces the national cap).
  • Local Option Schemes: Voluntary council uptake will dictate whether community-specific financing programs—such as council-facilitated energy or solar loan schemes—are made available to local residents.

Other Considerations for Your Budget

Beyond local rates, other aspects of your fixed-income budget intersect with current election policies:

  • Power and Insurance: National's energy policies target electricity supply and competition to address power bills, while broader inflation and insurance pressures remain heavily influenced by global markets and natural disaster resilience.
  • Healthcare: As a retiree relying on regular healthcare, your costs are heavily impacted by Pharmac funding decisions, primary care/GP subsidies, and wait times in the public health system, which are governed by central health targets rather than local councils.

Are there specific healthcare or cost-of-living pressures you are weighing most heavily as you make your voting decision?

Ask Gemini

Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

Captured 23 October 2026 · shown as Gemini gave it, not a verified account

Google AI Mode · No location

I'm retired, own my home and rely mainly on NZ Super. Rates, insurance and power bills are rising in importance for my budget, and I need regular healthcare. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. What could national party policies change about local rates, and what would still be decided by councils?

When living on a fixed income like NZ Super , managing fixed household costs is a central concern. The National Party’s policy platform introduces direct central government intervention in local authority pricing, reshaping how local rates can grow.

What National Party Policies Could Change About Local Rates

  • Capping Annual Rate Increases: Under the Local Government (Rates Capping) Amendment Bill introduced by National, legislation is moving through Parliament to restrict annual local authority rate increases.

  • The Target Range: The framework sets a target range for annual rate rises (an interim target of 2--4% per rating unit is prescribed before full implementation). Double-digit yearly rate increases by councils would require specific regulatory or ministerial exemptions (such as for extreme emergencies or critical infrastructure catch-up).

  • Timeline for Implementation: Councils are required to factor these caps into long-term planning from mid-2027, with the formal enforcement mechanisms and full caps taking strict effect by July 2029. [National Party]

  • Refocusing on Core Services: National’s policy intends to legally compel councils to restrict spending to "fixing the basics"—such as local roading,ing, water infrastructure, and rubbish collection—rather than funding non-essential community "nice-to-haves" that drive up costs. [National Party]

  • Solar/Energy Scheme Options: National has also proposed enabling low-interest home solar financing frameworks that can be tied to and repaid via property rates, aiming to lower ongoing household power expenses over time.


What Would Still Be Decided by Councils

Despite central government caps and legislative steering, local authorities retain significant independent authority over their jurisdictions:

  • The Underlying Valuations and Base Assessment: Councils independently determine property revaluation cycles and how the total rates burden is distributed across different property types or land values within the community.

  • Service Level Decisions: Within the core mandated basics, local elected councillors still decide the specific standard of service—such as how frequently rubbish is collected, the pace of local park maintenance, or local community facility hours.

  • Non-Capped Revenue & User Charges: Certain fees, commercial lease revenues, special development contributions, and specific water/infrastructure charges or targeted levies can sit outside standard general rate caps depending on the final scope of the legislation.

  • Prioritising Within the Cap: If a council faces rising costs or inflation in its operations, it must independently decide which local projects to cut, defer, or scale back to stay within the legal 2--4% ceiling without needing to apply to a central government regulator for an exception.

Would you like to explore how other political parties' 2026 policies approach fixed costs like power and health , or would you prefer a look at how rates rebates currently function for NZ Superannuitants?

Ask anything

Captured 23 October 2026 · shown as Google AI Mode gave it, not a verified account

AI Overviews · No location

I'm retired, own my home and rely mainly on NZ Super. Rates, insurance and power bills are rising in importance for my budget, and I need regular healthcare. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. What could national party policies change about local rates, and what would still be decided by councils?

AI Overview

For a retired homeowner living on NZ Super, managing fixed costs like local council rates is critical. Under the National Party’s 2026 election policies , the landscape of local government funding is proposed to shift toward centralized limits, though everyday operational decisions remain local.

Here is how National's policies could directly impact your local rates bills versus what your local council would still control.


🛑 What National Party Policies Would Change

The most significant policy shift impacting your household budget is National’s commitment to cap council rates increases.

  • The 4% Rates Cap: National has introduced legislation to mandatory cap annual council rates increases at a maximum of 4 percent per capita. Under this policy, councils are required to keep general rates, targeted rates, and uniform annual charges within a strict initial target range of 2% to 4%.

  • Exceptions to the Cap: A council can only exceed this 4% cap with explicit regulator approval under extreme circumstances, such as responding to a major natural disaster or severe infrastructure underinvestment.

  • Timeline: The transition into this model begins in 2027, with the full regulatory cap taking maximum legal effect by 2029.

  • New Tools for Infrastructure: To prevent councils from raising rates to pay for new housing developments, National passed the Infrastructure Funding and Financing Amendment Act. This enables infrastructure for new growth areas to be paid for by private investors and repaid over time by levies on the specific developers and new properties benefiting from it, rather than pushing the debt onto existing ratepayers.


🏛️ What Local Councils Would Still Decide

While central government policies dictate the upper legal limit of your rate increases, local councils retain complete autonomy over how they run their internal budgets within that cap. Your specific council will still decide:

  • The Exact Rate Percentage: Councils do not have to set the maximum 4% increase; they can choose a lower rate or freeze increases entirely if their budget allows.

  • Where the Money Goes: Your council will decide how to allocate its funding across essential community services—such as rubbish collection, road maintenance and potholes, public parks, and local libraries.

  • Service Reductions: Because a 4% cap restricts how much money a council can bring in, your local council will have to choose what services to cut, delay, or outsource to remain under the cap.

  • Water Charges: National’s rate cap policy explicitly excludes water charges. Any user-pays water infrastructure fees or volumetric water billing will still be managed and priced independently by your local council or local water provider.


💡 Additional Cost-of-Living Context for Your Budget

Because you mentioned power bills and health care are growing pressures on your fixed income, keep these aligned National policies in mind:

  • Power Bills: National has campaigned on policies to protect residential consumers from skyrocketing energy costs, including requiring large commercial entities (like new data centers) to bring their own power supply so they do not drive up electricity prices for households.

  • Healthcare: National’s 2026 policies focus heavily on health funding, including boosting specific cancer treatments, building regional training facilities like the Waikato Medical School to solve doctor shortages, and funding regional hospitals.


If you want to look closer at your budget, let me know:

  • Would you like to compare National's rates cap policy directly against Labour or the Greens' alternative local government funding plans?

  • Do you want information on current central government support schemes, like the Rates Rebate Scheme or the Winter Energy Payment?

Ask anything

Captured 23 October 2026 · shown as AI Overviews gave it, not a verified account