Evidence · NZ Election 2026 · Edition 3

Every question, every answer, every source

All 174 questions and the 793 answers produced on 16 October 2026. The 27 remaining cells produced no AI Overview.

questions
174
answers saved
793
collected
16 Oct 2026

01

Every question, with its answers

Each question was written as a voter would ask it and went to all four assistants. Some were also asked from a town. Open a question to read every answer to it in full.

Showing 20 of 174 questions

02

The tables behind the study

Every figure on the study page comes from these tables. They are CSV files, which open in any spreadsheet.

  • Questions

    nz-election-2026-questions.csv

    One row per unchanged question.

    id, draft, text, voterCode, issue, towns

  • Answers

    nz-election-2026-answers.csv

    One row per produced answer, with its complete original text. Parties covers all 17 tracked parties; displayed parties covers the seven charted parties.

    result id, prompt id, draft id, scenario id, platform, region, words, parties, displayed parties, literal url answer, temporal pair, common four platforms, response text

  • Sources by answer

    nz-election-2026-sources.csv

    One row per website associated with an answer; repeated citations count once.

    answer id, question id, assistant, region, domain, publisher

  • Checks against official sources

    nz-election-2026-checks.csv

    One row per reviewed claim and assistant, including cells where the assertion was not stated.

    checkId, claimToTest, category, answerId, questionId, assistant, assertionPresent, assertion, verdict, whatTheSourceSays, checkedOn, evidence

  • Who to vote for: coding

    nz-election-2026-guidance.csv

    One row per manually reviewed guidance answer. Codes overlap; original answers supply the evidence.

    draft, assistant, q, voter, a, declined, matched, shortlist, asked, chose, extract

  • Location and national answers

    nz-election-2026-towns.csv

    One row per matched national/location pair in this edition.

    edition, prompt id, platform, city region, national result id, city result id, same party names, same text

  • Changes between editions

    nz-election-2026-comparisons.csv

    All 17 tracked parties; one row per identical question, assistant and location across the 12 and 16 October collections. Earlier coding restated after the 20 October identity correction.

    earlier edition, prompt id, platform, region, draft id, block, scenario id, scenario, issue, priority, earlier result id, current result id, same party set, added, removed, earlier parties, current parties

  • No AI Overview produced

    nz-election-2026-coverage.csv

    One row per planned cell where no AI Overview was produced.

    questionId, assistant, collectionSetting, askedFrom, availability

  • Party-identity corrections

    nz-election-2026-party-identity-corrections.csv

    Ten reviewed false matches removed from the restated Edition 2 and current Edition 3 comparisons; original answer text is unchanged.

    edition, result id, party, before present, include, reason, reviewer, reviewed on

Use these tables to trace findings back to the original questions and answers. The full text of each answer is also on this page, under its question.

03

Read in full and checked

Some answers were read in detail or checked against official sources. Those appear on the study page, beside the findings they support.

ChatGPT · No location

I'm a tertiary student renting a room, working part time and using a student loan. I am struggling to fit paid work around study. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How do parties compare on student allowances, living-cost support and student loans?

If your main concern is “I need enough money to study without having to work so many hours that study suffers”, the parties are quite different in 2026.

The election is 7 November 2026, and I’m comparing policies that have actually been announced as of 16 October 2026, rather than older promises that may no longer be current. Reuters

First: what you can get under the current system

As of 1 April 2026, a single student aged 24+ living away from home can receive up to $380.43/week after tax in Student Allowance, although it is reduced by your own income. If you're under 24 and living away from home, the maximum is $333.38/week after tax, with parental-income testing also potentially applying. StudyLink

The Student Loan's living-cost component is currently up to $333.48/week. If you receive some Student Allowance, your living-cost borrowing is reduced so that the two together don't exceed $333.48/week. StudyLink

If you're receiving Student Allowance and renting rather than living with your parents, you may also get the $60/week Accommodation Benefit. StudyLink

One particularly important point for you: your part-time wages can reduce your Student Allowance. The current rules use a personal-income threshold of $284.70/week before the allowance starts being reduced. Legislation New Zealand

So the practical question isn't just “which party gives students more?” It's also “which party makes it possible for me to work fewer hours?”

How the major parties compare

Party Student allowance / income support Student loans What it could mean for you
Greens Universal student income, including postgraduate students Reduce loan repayments; work toward debt write-off and fees-free tertiary education Strongest direct support if your priority is reducing the amount you need to work
NZ First Wants to investigate a universal Student Allowance, without parental means-testing Lower mandatory repayment rate; targeted debt write-offs for critical workers Potentially very significant, but less certain because the allowance proposal is an investigation rather than a firm universal-payment commitment
Labour No major new universal Student Allowance announced 10% of eligible student debt written off; $2,000-or-less balances eventually cleared Stronger benefit after graduation than during study
National Existing Student Allowance system; has announced +$22/week for a single over-24 Student Allowance recipient Reduce compulsory repayment from 12% to 10% Some help while studying, and more take-home pay once you're earning
ACT No comparable universal student-income proposal Focuses on reducing costs rather than forgiving debt; wants voluntary Student Services Fees More market/user-pays approach; potentially lowers some costs but doesn't substantially replace your part-time income
Te Pāti Māori No clearly specified universal student allowance in its published 2026 material that I could find No similarly detailed student-loan proposal identified Less directly targeted to your particular problem
Opportunity $19,400/year Citizen's Income for adults, replacing Student Allowance Student Allowance would effectively disappear as a separate payment Potentially transformative if enacted, but involves a major tax/welfare-system redesign

🟢 Greens: strongest fit if your priority is reducing paid work

The Green Party's 2026 tertiary policy is unusually direct: it proposes a universal student income, including for postgraduate students, and says courses requiring work placements should pay at least the living wage. It also proposes reducing student-loan repayments and working towards fees-free tertiary education and student-debt write-off. Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand

And this is not merely an abstract commitment. Today, 16 October, the Greens announced a $380/week universal payment for students undertaking compulsory placements in nursing, teaching, social work and other specified essential-workforce programmes, on top of existing Student Allowance or Student Loan support, plus a $1,500 relocation payment where necessary. Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand

For someone struggling to fit employment around study, the important distinction is that the Greens' approach is to increase the amount of support you receive for being a student, rather than primarily asking you to borrow more or work more.

Green Party 2026 tertiary policy

🔴 Labour: particularly attractive if your concern is the debt you'll leave with

Labour's headline student policy is not a bigger allowance. Instead, it promises to cut eligible student-loan balances by 10%.

If you've already finished studying and are still repaying a qualifying loan, the 10% reduction would happen on 1 April 2027. Current and future students would qualify after finishing study and remaining in New Zealand for three years. Balances of $2,000 or less would be completely cleared after that three-year period. The scheme excludes people who benefited from Fees Free. Labour Party NZ

Labour also has a broader cost-of-living programme, including cheaper public transport, which could matter considerably if commuting is one of your expenses. Labour Party NZ

So I'd characterise Labour as “less debt and lower living costs”, rather than “give students substantially more income while they're studying.”

Labour's student-debt policy

🔵 National: modestly better cash flow, particularly if you're already eligible for Allowance

National's specific student measure is a $22/week increase for a single person over 24 receiving Student Allowance. National says around 52,000 students would receive additional assistance. National Party

For student loans, National proposes reducing the compulsory repayment rate from 12% to 10% from 1 April 2027. That doesn't help much while you're studying on a low income, but becomes meaningful once you graduate and earn above the repayment threshold. National Party

National is therefore the more incremental option: some extra support now, lower repayments later, but no fundamental change to student income support.

🟡 NZ First: potentially big change, but less certain

NZ First's published tertiary policy proposes investigating a universal Student Allowance not subject to parental means-testing for all full-time students. It also proposes changing the mandatory repayment rate to 10%, removing mandatory repayments for certain students earning below the median wage, and targeted student-loan write-offs for people working in identified skill-shortage occupations. New Zealand First

That could be highly relevant if you're under 24 and your parents' income currently affects your allowance.

The catch is important: “investigate introducing” isn't the same as a guaranteed payment. I'd give this less weight than a fully costed, explicit commitment.

🟠 ACT: more about reducing the cost of tertiary education than increasing income

ACT's student policy is principally about choice and reducing compulsory fees. It proposes making Student Services Fees voluntary rather than compulsory, saying students could save up to around $4,000 over a three-year degree through their student loan. ACT New Zealand

That's potentially useful, but it addresses a different problem from yours. It reduces the amount going onto your loan, rather than giving you enough weekly income that you can work fewer hours.

🟣 Opportunity: the radical alternative

Opportunity's proposal is arguably the most dramatic for a student financially.

It proposes a $19,400-a-year Citizen's Income for every citizen and resident aged 18+, paid fortnightly and tax-free. It would replace the existing Student Allowance as well as several other benefits. 1News

That's roughly $373/week.

The catch is that Opportunity would fundamentally redesign the tax-and-benefit system to pay for it, including a 28% income-tax rate up to $50,000. So you shouldn't compare the $19,400 with a Student Allowance in isolation—the overall effect on your disposable income depends on your wages and circumstances.

What I'd focus on in your situation

If I reduce the policies to your actual problem—“I can't fit enough paid work around my study”:

  1. Greens — clearest commitment to substantially increasing student income/support. Their universal student income directly targets student poverty and reliance on employment/borrowing.
  2. Opportunity — potentially even more dramatic through the Citizen's Income, but it's a much bigger tax/welfare restructuring and therefore a less straightforward comparison.
  3. NZ First — potentially strong, especially if parental means-testing is a problem, but its universal allowance remains an investigation rather than a definite commitment.
  4. National — relatively modest improvement to current Student Allowance; more beneficial to borrowers once they're earning.
  5. Labour — strongest of these mainstream options on reducing the debt you eventually repay, but comparatively little new cash support while you're studying.
  6. ACT — could reduce some tertiary costs and therefore borrowing, but doesn't really solve the “I need to work fewer hours” problem.

That's a ranking only on the student-finance question you've asked, not an overall ranking of the parties.

One other thing I'd be careful about: don't assume that “more Student Loan living costs” means you're better off. A loan can solve your weekly cash-flow problem while leaving you with substantially more debt. The Greens' universal income, Opportunity's Citizen's Income, and NZ First's proposed universal allowance are qualitatively different because they aim to provide more support without simply turning the shortfall into borrowing.

If you tell me your age, whether you currently receive Student Allowance, roughly how much you earn per week from your job, and roughly how much you pay in rent/board, I can turn this into a personalised dollar comparison of what each party's policy would likely mean for you per week and after graduation.

Ask anything

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

Captured 16 October 2026 · shown as ChatGPT gave it, not a verified account

Gemini · No location

I'm a tertiary student renting a room, working part time and using a student loan. I am struggling to fit paid work around study. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How do parties compare on student allowances, living-cost support and student loans?

Balancing a part-time job, full-time study, and a student loan while trying to cope with the cost of living is a major squeeze. In the 2026 New Zealand general election, political parties have drawn distinct battle lines around tertiary education costs, debt write-offs, and financial support for students.

How the major parties compare on student allowances, living-cost support, and student loans shapes up as follows:


1. National

National’s approach focuses on economic growth, targeted relief for graduates, and keeping student loan schemes active while easing immediate post-study repayment burdens.

  • Student Loans & Repayments: National is proposing to cut the compulsory student loan repayment rate from 12% to 10% (starting April 2027) for borrowers living in New Zealand. Conversely, they favor tightening rules and raising interest/enforcement for borrowers living overseas.
  • Fees-Free & Allowances: The National-led government scrapped the previous first-year fees-free scheme in Budget 2026, arguing it did not effectively lift overall participation. National has not introduced sweeping universal student allowances or broad debt write-offs, maintaining a user-pays tertiary model supported by the loan scheme.

2. Labour

Labour’s 2026 campaign package targets post-study debt and cost-of-living pressures, alongside broader measures like public transport caps and health access.

  • Student Loans & Debt Relief: Labour has pledged to cut student debt by 10% for New Zealand-based graduates who missed out on fees-free (taking effect April 2027), and to completely clear student loan balances of $2,000 or less. For current and future students, this 10% reduction will apply after they spend three years working in New Zealand post-study.
  • Living-Cost Support: While falling short of a total overhaul of student allowances, Labour's wider cost-of-living package includes targeted support like public transport fare caps (e.g., $20 a week in major centers), free primary healthcare/prescriptions expansions, and training incentives like the Apprenticeship Boost.

3. Green Party

The Greens campaign on the most comprehensive structural overhaul of student finances, pushing for systemic change to eliminate student poverty.

  • Allowances & Income: The Greens advocate for a universal student income available to all students regardless of parental income, designed to remove the hurdle of fitting heavy paid work around intensive study hours.
  • Fees-Free & Student Debt: Their 2026 manifesto commits to officially restoring and expanding fees-free tertiary education, working towards a total student debt write-off, and lowering ongoing loan repayment hurdles.

4. Te Pāti Māori

Te Pāti Māori leans heavily into removing financial barriers for rangatahi (youth) and tertiary learners.

  • Allowances & Loans: Te Pāti Māori supports a universal student allowance to ensure students receive an independent income.
  • Debt Write-offs: They have pledged to immediately write off the living-cost component of all student debt and completely wipe the remainder of student loans for graduates who stay and work in New Zealand for five years.

5. ACT New Zealand

ACT takes a free-market approach, strongly opposing government subsidies and debt forgiveness.

  • Student Loans & Fees: ACT supports user-pays principles and backed the termination of the fees-free tertiary scheme, arguing that general taxpayers shouldn't subsidize tertiary study without clear universal public benefit. They historically advocate against broad student loan write-offs, positioning them as costly to the wider economy.

Summary Table for Your Situation

Party Stance on Student Loans / Debt Stance on Allowances & Living Support
National Lower repayment rate from 12% to 10% for NZ-based earners; no general write-off. Focuses on broader economic management rather than student-specific benefit expansions.
Labour 10% cut to existing debt for NZ-based graduates (or after 3 years working in NZ); full clearance for debts under $2,000. Broader cost-of-living relief (e.g., public transport caps, health costs).
Greens Work toward a total student debt write-off and lower repayments. Implement a universal student income; restore fees-free.
Te Pāti Māori Immediate write-off of living-cost debt; total wipe after 5 years working in NZ. Universal student allowance.
ACT Opposes write-offs and fees-free schemes; favors strict loan repayment enforcement. Relies on market solutions and personal/family responsibility rather than student welfare expansions.

Depending on your situation, parties like the Greens and Te Pāti Māori offer direct relief for your current living costs via universal allowances, while Labour and National focus more on adjusting post-study repayment mechanics or slicing percentages off your overall ledger once you enter the workforce.

Which of these approaches—immediate living-cost income reform versus post-study debt reduction—feels most critical to your day-to-day survival right now?

Ask Gemini

Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

Captured 16 October 2026 · shown as Gemini gave it, not a verified account

Google AI Mode · No location

I'm a tertiary student renting a room, working part time and using a student loan. I am struggling to fit paid work around study. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How do parties compare on student allowances, living-cost support and student loans?

For a tertiary student juggling part-time work, a student loan, and living costs ahead of the 2026 New Zealand general election , political parties have drawn distinct lines regarding student support, loan repayment thresholds, and allowances.

The major party policy positions compare across key areas as follows:

1. Student Loans & Repayment Rates

  • National: Pledges to reduce the compulsory student loan repayment rate from 12% to 10% for incomes over the threshold ($24,128) starting April 2027. To offset this and target overseas default, National proposes increasing annual interest for overseas-based borrowers (by 1% to 6.6%), restricting overseas KiwiSaver withdrawals until loans are cleared, and tightening enforcement/warrant rules for chronic defaulters.

  • Labour: Proposes cutting 10% off eligible student loan balances for New Zealand-based graduates who stay, work, and meet obligations domestically (taking effect April 2027 for past graduates, or after 3 years of domestic residency for current/future students). Balances left at $2,000 or less after 3 years would be wiped entirely. (Excludes those who used the Fees Free scheme).

  • ACT: Focuses heavily on structural costs rather than debt write-offs, proposing to make compulsory Student Services Fees voluntary rather than automatically bundled by tertiary institutions. ACT estimates this can save students up to $4,000 over a standard three-year degree, though it shifts funding for campus recreation and advocacy to a user-pays model.

2. Living-Cost Support & Allowances for Placements

  • Green Party: Announced a targeted living-cost support policy addressing unpaid professional placements. The Greens promise a universal weekly payment of $380 (on top of existing student allowances or loans) for students undertaking compulsory, unpaid practical placements in critical workforce areas like nursing, teaching, social work, midwifery, and counselling. It also includes a $1,500 relocation payment for students forced to move away from home for these placements.

  • Labour & National: Current general living-cost adjustments and student allowance settings largely follow indexed annual adjustments, though neither major party has campaigned on a total overhaul to universal student allowances for all general study streams in 2026, instead focusing their tertiary spending on debt reductions and repayment adjustments.


If you want to narrow this down further, let me know:

  • Are you studying a specific professional degree (like nursing or teaching) that involves unpaid practicums?
  • Are you currently eligible for the student allowance , or relying purely on the living-costs loan?

I can provide more tailored details on how these specific policies impact your budget.

Ask anything

Captured 16 October 2026 · shown as Google AI Mode gave it, not a verified account

AI Overviews · No location

I'm a tertiary student renting a room, working part time and using a student loan. I am struggling to fit paid work around study. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How do parties compare on student allowances, living-cost support and student loans?

AI Overview

Major political parties in New Zealand offer distinct approaches to student allowances, living-cost support, and student loans ahead of the 2026 general election :

New Zealand Labour Party

  • Student Loans: Pledges to write off 10% of eligible student loan balances for New Zealand-based graduates who did not benefit from the fees-free scheme and stay in the country for at least three years post-study. Borrowers with a total balance of $2,000 or less will have their entire debt wiped.
  • Living-Cost Support: Focuses on wider cost-of-relief measures rather than overhauling the core student allowance system, including capping public transport fares, free GP visits, and supermarket anti-price-gouging laws.
  • Fees / Study Costs: Criticises National's fee hikes and maintains support for targeted tertiary affordability.

New Zealand National Party

  • Student Loans: Proposes lowering the compulsory student loan repayment rate from 12 cents to 10 cents for every dollar earned above $24,128 (starting April 1, 2027), giving borrowers more take-home pay while extending the timeframe to clear total debt.
  • Living-Cost Support & Allowances: Maintains the existing means-tested student allowance framework, pointing to general adjustments like inflation indexation and tax/family-credit updates. Has opposed blanket debt write-offs, arguing they shift the financial burden onto general taxpayers.

Green Party

  • Student Loans & Incomes: Advocates moving toward fees-free tertiary education and comprehensive debt write-offs, alongside reforming overseas student loan repayment rules and ending border actions against non-resident borrowers.
  • Living-Cost Support / Paid Placements: Announced a policy to provide a universal weekly stipend/paid placement via StudyLink for students completing mandatory practical training in essential sectors (such as nursing, teaching, counselling, social work, and health) to stop unpaid placements from forcing students to drop out or go broke.

ACT New Zealand

  • Student Loans & Fees: Critiques debt write-offs and interest-free loan structures as inefficient, arguing for smaller government, deregulation, and a focus on broad economic growth rather than targeted student subsidies.

Te Pāti Māori

  • Student Allowances & Loans: Proposes a universal student allowance (removing parental income-testing thresholds) and immediately writing off the living-cost portion of student debt, plus completely wiping student loans for graduates who remain working in New Zealand for five years.

If you want to narrow this down further, let me know:

  • Are you studying in a sector with unpaid practical placements (like nursing or teaching)?
  • Are you currently locked out of the Student Allowance due to parental income testing?
Ask anything

Captured 16 October 2026 · shown as AI Overviews gave it, not a verified account