Evidence · NZ Election 2026 · Edition 7

Every question and original answer

Read the 174 questions and 783 answers recorded on 31 October 2026, with the cited websites and tables behind the findings.

questions
174
answers saved
783
collected
31 October 2026

01

Every question, with its answers

Each question was written as a voter would ask it and went to all four assistants. Some were also asked from a town. Open a question to read every answer to it in full.

Showing 20 of 174 questions

02

The tables behind the study

Every figure on the study page comes from these tables. They are CSV files, which open in any spreadsheet.

  • Questions

    questions.csv

    One row per question, with its original wording.

    id, text, reference, enabled, axes, collectionSettings

  • Complete answers

    answers.csv

    One row per saved answer, including its original text.

    id, questionId, assistant, collectionSetting, askedFrom, text, words

  • Answers included in each comparison

    memberships.csv

    One row per answer and comparison, showing which results were counted together.

    comparisonId, answerId, rowKey, included

  • Party names found in answers

    codings.csv

    One row per answer, party and comparison, with the recorded decision and evidence.

    comparisonId, answerId, entityId, kind, measure, counted, quote, reason, evidence

  • Sources recorded with each answer

    sources.csv

    One row per answer, listing its cited websites, visible links and whether source information was available.

    answerId, capture, domains, urls, literalUrls, origin

  • Answers compared across editions

    pairs.csv

    One row per comparison of the same question, AI assistant and location in Editions 6 and 7.

    earlierAnswerId, answerId, questionId, assistant, collectionSetting, askedFrom

  • Checks across editions

    edition-checks.csv

    The selected checks and whether their statements appeared in each edition.

    checkId, claim, assistant, earlierAnswerId, answerId, earlierQuote, quote, trajectory, assessment, evidence

  • What the voting-guidance answers did

    behaviour-coding.csv

    One row per guidance answer, with the recorded behaviours and supporting passages.

    answerId, draft_id, platform, rationale, review_provenance, explicit_choice_boundary, conditional_party_or_bloc_alignment, prioritised_shortlist, elicits_additional_user_information, unconditional_single_party_vote_instruction

  • Checks against official sources

    checks.csv

    One row per selected statement checked in an answer.

    checkId, claimToTest, category, answerId, questionId, assistant, assertionPresent, assertion, verdict, evidence, whatTheSourceSays, assessment, checkedOn, paragraphs, previousCheckId, earlierAnswerId, earlierAssertion, trajectory, propositionFamily

  • Statements selected for checking

    check-register.csv

    One row per selected check, with its reason and official source.

    checkId, claimToTest, category, whyChecked, primarySourceUrl, answerId

  • Research findings

    findings.csv

    One row per finding, with its figure and supporting records.

    id, value, denominator, statement, summary, evidence, caveat

  • What changed for each voter

    case-decisions.csv

    One row per voter situation, with the earlier and later readings.

    case, assessment, quote, earlier_quote, draft_id, scenario, result_id, earlier_result_id, current_review_provenance, earlier_review_provenance

  • Answers read in detail

    report-evidence.csv

    One row per answer included in the detailed research readings.

    key, answerId, interpretation, text

  • Party counts by edition

    party-count-tables.csv

    One row per comparison, edition, assistant and party, with its answer count and total.

    panel, edition, platform, party, numerator, denominator

  • Answer length by assistant

    platform-tables.csv

    One row per comparison, edition and assistant, with the recorded answer lengths.

    panel, edition, platform, answers, median_words, total_words

  • Location comparisons by edition

    regional-tables.csv

    One row per national-and-location comparison and edition.

    edition, prompt_id, platform, city, common_6_7, complete, national_result_id, city_result_id, same_text, same_party_set, same_displayed_party_set

  • Party counts by topic

    issue-tables.csv

    One row per topic and edition, counting all saved answers in that edition.

    issue, edition, answers, median_words, party_counts

  • Links visible in answers

    literal-source-evidence.csv

    One row per answer, with the web links present in its text.

    edition, result_id, literal_urls, literal_domains, associated_capture

  • Separate website reference totals

    aggregate-references.csv

    One row per website in the separate reference summary; these totals do not identify which answer used it.

    domain, citationCount, referenceCount, promptCount, urlTotal, trendTotal, platforms

  • Changes between repeated answers

    pair-metrics.csv

    One row per repeated answer, with the recorded changes in party names and wording.

    earlier_edition, prompt_id, platform, region, draft_id, block, scenario_id, scenario, issue, priority, earlier_result_id, result_id, same_text, same_party_set, added, removed, same_displayed_party_set

  • Statements and sentiment assessments

    claims.csv

    Saved sentiment assessments of statements about parties, with answer references and quotations from the original answers where available.

    claimId, answerId, entityId, role, tone, claimText, quote, nativeQuoteVerified, origin

  • Original saved statement assessments

    raw-native-claims.csv

    One row per saved statement, with its original wording and party assessments. These are automated results, not independently checked facts.

    quote, brands, stance, claimId, claimText, sourceResultId

  • Original saved source records

    raw-native-sources.csv

    Every saved source record, distinguishing citations from other references. The source rankings count citations only.

    answerId, url, domain, metadata, domainType, citationKind

  • Party-name context checks

    party-identity-decisions.csv

    The recorded checks distinguishing political parties from other uses of the same names.

    id, party, contexts, entityId, counted, reason, scope

  • Websites cited across editions

    source-reach-tables.csv

    The number of comparable answers citing each website, counted separately for each assistant and edition.

    edition, scope, assistant, domain, answers, totalAnswers

  • Sources by answer

    source-associations.csv

    One row per answer and website; repeated references to the same website count once.

    answer id, question id, assistant, domain, publisher

  • National and location answers

    place-pairs.csv

    One row per complete national-and-location pair in this edition.

    question id, assistant, place, national answer id, place answer id, national entities, place entities, same entities

Use these tables to trace findings back to the original questions and answers. The full text of each answer is also on this page, under its question.

03

Read in full and checked

Some answers were read in detail or checked against official sources. Those appear on the study page, beside the findings they support.

ChatGPT · No location

For the 2026 New Zealand general election: What would the parties change about electricity prices, fuel costs and the security of energy supply?

2026 New Zealand election: Electricity, fuel and energy security

The central difference between the parties is how they believe New Zealand should achieve cheaper energy and a more reliable supply.

As at 31 October 2026, the main approaches are:

  • National and ACT: Encourage private investment, build more generation and retain gas or LNG as backup.
  • Labour: Help households reduce electricity bills through solar, strengthen consumer protections and provide some direct fuel-tax relief.
  • Greens: Increase public ownership of electricity generation and accelerate renewable energy, storage and electrification.
  • NZ First: Restructure electricity companies, explore domestic oil and gas and strengthen fuel security.
  • Te Pāti Māori: Increase Māori and community ownership of renewable energy and strengthen local energy independence.

There is considerable agreement that New Zealand needs more electricity. The disagreement is over who should own it, how it should be generated, and how much government should intervene in prices. The politics of power: Comparing energy policies ahead of Election 2026Power Prices for 2026NZ Political Party Energy Policies — 2026

1. What each party proposes

Party Electricity prices Petrol and diesel costs Security of supply
National More generation and competition; loans for household solar, batteries and insulation No major direct petrol-price reduction promise identified in its main energy package Supports domestic gas development and LNG imports as backup, alongside renewables
Labour SolarSaver loans and subsidies; stronger action against electricity price gouging Freeze fuel excise tax for three years; estimated average family saving of $520 a year by 2030 Supports renewables and household generation; proposes restoring the ban on new oil and gas exploration
Greens Publicly owned Kiwipower to invest in generation; zero-interest household clean-energy loans No equivalent general petrol-tax reduction identified in the policies reviewed More renewable generation, batteries and public investment; opposes LNG imports
ACT More private investment, competition and fewer regulatory barriers No major direct pump-price reduction identified in its main energy proposals Supports gas and LNG as backup while new generation is developed
NZ First Separate electricity generation and retail businesses to increase competition Remove the ETS charge on fuel; claims this would immediately reduce petrol by 12–14 cents per litre More domestic oil and gas exploration, fuel reserves and development of Marsden Point
Te Pāti Māori Stronger regulation of excessive prices and greater community ownership No comparable nationwide petrol-tax reduction identified Community-owned renewables, batteries and energy independence rather than LNG dependence
The Opportunities Party (TOP) Focus on expanding energy supply and investment No comparable major petrol-price measure identified Supports greater energy investment and business electrification incentives

Sources: party announcements and policy comparisons. Power Prices for 2026Energy, climate and environment policy guideWe Want Cheaper Power And We Want Our People To Own It.NZ Political Party Energy Policies — 2026NZFirst to Remove Climate Tax From FuelThe politics of power: Comparing energy policies ahead of Election 2026

2. More detail on electricity prices

Here is what the major proposals mean in practice.

National: Build more electricity and encourage competition

Market-led approach

National's Electrify NZ 2.0 and wider energy package include:

  • Faster approvals for wind, solar, hydro and other generation.
  • More private investment in electricity generation and transmission.
  • A Home Energy Fund offering long-term loans for solar panels, batteries, insulation and heat pumps.
  • Allowing households to sell surplus solar electricity to the retailer offering the best price.
  • LNG imports and domestic gas as backup when renewable generation is insufficient.

National also wants affordability to become an explicit objective for the Electricity Authority. Power Prices for 20262026 Election Policy

Labour: Help households generate their own electricity

Household affordability approach

Labour's headline proposal is its $160 million SolarSaver programme.

It would:

  • Provide government-backed finance for solar panels and batteries.
  • Offer eligible low- and middle-income households up to $3,000 in additional assistance.
  • Help renters access plug-in solar.
  • Support community batteries.
  • Improve the payments households receive for exporting solar electricity.
  • Make electricity price gouging illegal, with stronger Commerce Commission enforcement.

Labour estimates participating households could save around $1,000 annually on power bills. This is a party estimate, not a guaranteed saving for every household. Labour's Cost of Living PlanPower Prices for 2026

Greens: Establish a publicly owned electricity generator

Public ownership approach

The Greens' central proposal is Kiwipower, a publicly owned energy company.

It would:

  • Invest in renewable electricity generation.
  • Provide additional backup generation to address dry-year shortages.
  • Help stabilise electricity supply and affordability.
  • Support community-owned renewable projects.
  • Offer zero-interest loans for household solar and batteries.
  • Expand solar access for renters and public housing.

The Greens argue that the electricity market needs structural reform, rather than relying primarily on private generators to deliver affordable power. Power Prices for 2026NZ Political Party Energy Policies — 2026

ACT: Remove barriers to private investment

ACT wants more generation and competition without breaking up the major electricity generator-retailers.

Its proposals include:

  • Making it easier for private businesses to build generation and transmission infrastructure.
  • Removing unnecessary barriers to small-scale solar.
  • Encouraging investment in batteries and electricity storage.
  • Supporting gas and LNG as transitional backup.
  • Ensuring consumers are not burdened with unjustified network upgrade costs.

Power Prices for 2026NZ Political Party Energy Policies — 2026

NZ First: Break up the major electricity companies

Structural market reform

NZ First wants to:

  • Separate electricity generation companies from electricity retail companies.
  • Increase competition in the electricity market.
  • Invest in exploring New Zealand's oil, gas and geothermal resources.
  • Establish a special economic zone at Marsden Point for energy-related development.
  • Increase strategic fuel reserves.

The party argues that restructuring the electricity industry would improve competition and lower costs. Whether that would translate into lower household bills would depend on how the reforms worked in practice. Energy, climate and environment policy guideNZ Political Party Energy Policies — 2026

Te Pāti Māori: Energy sovereignty

Community ownership

Its September 2026 Energy Sovereignty policy proposes:

  • A $1 billion Energy Sovereignty Fund.
  • Investment in Māori and community-owned renewable energy.
  • Stronger powers to address excessive electricity prices and profits.
  • Fair payments for households and communities generating and storing electricity.
  • A long-term national energy plan.

Its objective is to have more energy infrastructure owned by local communities, iwi, hapū and whānau. We Want Cheaper Power And We Want Our People To Own It.NZ Political Party Energy Policies — 2026

3. What would happen to petrol and diesel prices?

This is an important distinction because electricity policy and transport fuel policy are not the same thing.

There are two particularly specific proposals:

Labour: Freeze fuel excise tax

$520

Estimated average family saving per year by 2030

  • Freeze fuel excise tax for three years.
  • Make excessive fuel pricing illegal.
  • Require companies found to have overcharged customers to repay them.

Labour's Cost of Living PlanLabour's 2026 Election Policies

NZ First: Remove the ETS fuel charge

12–14c/L

Claimed immediate reduction in petrol and diesel prices

  • Remove the Emissions Trading Scheme charge on petrol and diesel.
  • NZ First says this would reduce petrol by 12 cents and diesel by 14 cents per litre.

This is the party's estimate, not an independently guaranteed reduction at the pump. NZFirst to Remove Climate Tax From FuelElection policy tracker: what the parties are promising

For the other parties:

  • National: Its principal energy policies focus on electricity affordability and security rather than a specific reduction in petrol taxes.
  • ACT: Focuses on market competition and energy investment rather than a direct petrol-tax cut.
  • Greens: Focus on reducing dependence on fossil fuels through public transport, renewable electricity and electrification.
  • Te Pāti Māori: Focus on energy sovereignty and community-owned renewable energy rather than a specific nationwide petrol-tax reduction.

An important qualification: even if fuel taxes are reduced, international oil prices, the New Zealand dollar, shipping costs and distribution margins will continue to influence what motorists pay.

4. Which parties have different approaches to energy security?

This is arguably the biggest long-term policy disagreement.

New Zealand has a particular vulnerability: much of its electricity comes from hydro generation, meaning prolonged dry periods can reduce electricity availability and increase wholesale prices.

The parties have different ideas about how to deal with this.

Generation | Nova Energy

National, ACT and NZ First

Retain or expand access to gas and other firm energy sources. National and ACT support LNG backup, while NZ First places greater emphasis on domestic oil and gas exploration and fuel reserves.

Renewable Energy Zones: Bridging the gap for Northland’s electricity resilience and reliability

Labour and Greens

Place greater emphasis on renewable generation, solar, batteries and electrification. Labour would restore the oil and gas exploration ban; the Greens oppose LNG imports and propose public investment to improve dry-year security.

A meeting place - of tradition and technology.⁠Sunergise is delighted to have joined with Tesla in supporting the work of Te Ra at Manurewa Marae.⁠The 100 Trina Honey Black solar PV panels… | Sunergise

Te Pāti Māori

Prioritises community-owned renewable generation, energy storage and local energy independence rather than reliance on imported LNG.

The politics of power: Comparing energy policies ahead of Election 2026Power Prices for 2026We Want Cheaper Power And We Want Our People To Own It.NZ Political Party Energy Policies — 2026

5. Side-by-side summary

Issue Main policy differences
Cheaper electricity National and ACT favour competition and private investment; Labour favours household assistance and regulation; Greens favour public generation; NZ First favours restructuring; Te Pāti Māori favours community ownership.
Cheaper petrol Labour proposes a fuel-tax freeze; NZ First proposes removing the ETS fuel charge.
Domestic gas Supported by National, ACT and NZ First; Labour and Greens favour less reliance on new fossil-fuel development.
LNG imports Supported by National and ACT; opposed by Greens and Te Pāti Māori.
Renewable energy All parties recognise the importance of additional electricity supply, but differ on ownership, investment and the speed of transition.
Energy storage Broad agreement on the value of batteries and storage, although approaches and funding differ.

6. What should voters look at when comparing these policies?

There are three useful questions to ask of every party.

  1. Will my electricity bill actually fall? More generation does not automatically mean cheaper household electricity. Consider whether the party has a mechanism to pass savings through to consumers.

  2. Will petrol and diesel become cheaper? Distinguish between a tax reduction and a promise to reduce the underlying international cost of fuel.

  3. What happens during a dry year or an international fuel crisis? Consider whether the proposed mix of hydro, wind, solar, batteries, gas, LNG and fuel reserves can provide reliable supply.

One further distinction matters: a party's proposed policy is not the same as an implemented policy. Coalition negotiations, funding, legislation and infrastructure construction will affect what actually happens.

Sources for checking the policies

These are useful sources, including official party announcements and independent comparisons:

A useful next comparison would be how these policies could affect an ordinary household's annual electricity and petrol bills.

Compare estimated annual household savings under each party

Ask anything

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

Captured 31 October 2026 · shown as ChatGPT gave it, not a verified account

Gemini · No location

For the 2026 New Zealand general election: What would the parties change about electricity prices, fuel costs and the security of energy supply?

For the 2026 New Zealand general election, energy policy, pricing, and supply security have emerged as core battlegrounds. Following recent constraints on hydro lakes, high electricity costs for households and businesses, and debates over domestic gas, political parties have put forward distinct visions.

The major parties approach electricity prices, fuel costs, and security of supply through different mechanisms:


1. The National Party (Electrify NZ 2.0)

  • Electricity Prices & Competition: Focuses on increasing overall supply, speeding up private investment, and removing planning barriers for small-scale renewables. National proposes giving consumers more choice, allowing households with solar or batteries to sell excess electricity to the company offering the best deal, and making affordability an explicit statutory objective for the Electricity Authority (alongside competition, reliability, and efficiency). They also propose a Home Energy Fund to provide long-term loans for solar, batteries, and insulation.
  • Security of Supply: Backs a mix of expanded domestic gas development and a liquefied natural gas (LNG) import facility to act as crucial backup during dry years when hydro generation is constrained. They also require large-scale new energy-intensive projects like AI data centres to bring or build their own new renewable or firmed power generation.

2. The Labour Party (SolarSaver & Consumer Protection)

  • Electricity Prices: Focuses heavily on direct household relief and lowering power bills through a headline $160 million SolarSaver programme. This scheme provides government-backed low-interest finance, subsidies of up to $3,000 for low- and middle-income households, plug-in solar options for renters, and community battery funding. Labour also plans to crack down on corporate market power, making price gouging illegal and giving the Commerce Commission stronger enforcement powers.
  • Security of Supply & Fuel: Recommits to reinstating the ban on new oil and gas exploration. To handle industrial transitions away from fossil fuels, Labour supports business electrification partnerships and a loan guarantee scheme to help heavy users transition smoothly.

3. The Green Party (Power for All of Us)

  • Electricity Prices: Proposes zero-interest clean-energy loans for household solar and batteries, a legal right to solar for renters, and large-scale rollouts of solar across public and Māori housing.
  • Security of Supply: Advocates for establishing Kiwipower, a publicly-owned company tasked with investing in new renewable generation and explicitly filling gaps in "renewable firming capacity" that the market has historically failed to secure. The Greens also support strict renewable-energy, environmental, and water-use standards for new data centres.

4. ACT New Zealand

  • Electricity Prices & Market: Emphasizes a market-led, investment-driven approach to generation. ACT supports faster development of frequency-service markets to improve battery economics and wants to remove unnecessary regulatory procedures for residential and commercial solar installations.
  • Security of Supply & Fuel: Strongly supports near-term LNG backup for dry-year security and relies on a market-led framework coupled with the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) to let businesses flexibly choose their fuel sources (including gas and coal) without heavy-handed government bans.

5. New Zealand First

  • Electricity Prices & Market: Advocates for structural shifts in the electricity sector, remaining open to or pushing for measures to address the market dominance of the major gentailers (generation and retail companies), and has proposed structural separation or targeted market interventions to bring down consumer costs.
  • Security of Supply & Regional Development: Strongly backs domestic resource development (including oil and gas) to guarantee regional jobs and energy security. NZ First has proposed establishing a Special Economic Zone at Marsden Point centered around regional energy generation, distribution, and maritime activities.

Summary of Common Ground

Despite fierce debates over fossil fuels and market structures, all parties generally agree on a few forward-looking paths: reducing red tape for distributed/rooftop solar, enabling households and businesses to feed excess energy back into the grid more easily, and managing the massive electricity demand expected from future data centres and tech infrastructure.

Would you like to dive deeper into how a specific party’s policy might impact household power bills or commercial energy users?

Ask Gemini

Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

Captured 31 October 2026 · shown as Gemini gave it, not a verified account

Google AI Mode · No location

For the 2026 New Zealand general election: What would the parties change about electricity prices, fuel costs and the security of energy supply?

Heading into the 2026 New Zealand general election, political parties have outlined distinct approaches to addressing cost-of-living power bills, security of energy supply, and fuel or generation policies.

National Party (Electrify NZ 2.0 Plan)

  • Electricity Prices & Household Access: Focuses on lowering bills through household energy independence. Proposes launching a government-backed Home Energy Fund for low-interest loans for solar, batteries, and insulation. Removes consent requirements for most small-scale residential or on-farm solar and micro-hydro installations. Requires lines companies to approve residential and small-business solar connections within two working days (with compensation for delays) and lets households sell exported power to any retailer.

  • Regulation & Competition: Mandates affordability as a core legal objective for the Electricity Authority , opens electricity transmission to private investment, and reviews lines charge rules under the Commerce Act. Requires high-demand AI data centres to bring their own new, firmed power supply so they do not drive up consumer costs.

  • Security of Supply : Opens up the backup power market to level the playing field for dry-year mitigation.

Labour Party

  • Electricity Prices & Market Structure: Keeps "all options on the table" regarding the structural separation of the major gentailers (generators and retailers), noting that the current market framework is failing to properly support households and businesses.

  • Security of Supply & Fuel Policy: Proposes looking closely at building a fourth Rankine unit at the Huntly Power Station running on bioenergy to manage dry-year security risks. Reinstates the ban on offshore oil and gas exploration originally introduced in 2018 and opposes plans to develop an LNG import terminal.

New Zealand First

  • Electricity Prices & Market Structure: Proposes breaking up the major "gentailer" power companies by legally separating electricity generation from retail operations to remove combined control over power and prices.

  • Security of Supply & Competition: Aims to replace the existing market system to prevent generation companies from withholding supply to drive up pricing, while guaranteeing long-term, fixed-price contracts for new renewable generation projects. Supports expanding household solar export rights back into the grid.

Green Party

  • Electricity Prices & Household Access: Focuses on affordability and community resilience via a dedicated state-backed entity called Kiwipower to fill infrastructure gaps and accelerate the renewable transition. Proposes zero-interest clean energy loans, up to $3,000 in kickstart solar subsidies for low- and middle-income families and renters, and a $30 million community battery fund. Legalises "plug-in" solar panels to give renters access to self-generated power.

ACT New Zealand

  • Competition & Transmission: Emphasises market competition and fair access. Advocates for opening transmission to private investment—permitting private entities to build, own, and operate transmission connections to the national grid—and strengthening enforcement against market power misuse by major electricity firms.
Ask anything

Captured 31 October 2026 · shown as Google AI Mode gave it, not a verified account