Search studies, brands and more…⌘ KExplore research

Evidence · Home lending

The questions and original answers

Explore every question and captured response in the home-lending study, including answers asked nationally and from four cities.

questions
193
captured answers
1,094
AI platforms
4
collected
11 October 2026

01

Every question, with its answers

Each question was written as a voter would ask it and went to all four assistants. Some were also asked from a town. Open a question to read every answer to it in full.

Showing 20 of 193 questions

Show all 193

02

The tables behind the study

Every figure on the study page comes from these tables. They are CSV files, which open in any spreadsheet.

  • Question catalogue

    questions.csv

    One row per question.

    Question ID, borrower, exact question, group and collected answers

    193rows

    Download question catalogue (CSV)

  • Answers

    answers.csv

    One row per answer, with its full text.

    Answer ID, question ID, borrower, assistant, city, words, coded recommendations, showed a link and full text

    1,094rows

    Download answers (CSV)

  • Sources by answer

    sources.csv

    One row for each website recorded as a source of an answer.

    Answer ID, question ID, assistant, city, website and publisher type

    4,574rows

    Download sources by answer (CSV)

  • Checks against official sources

    checks.csv

    One row per statement checked.

    Check, answer ID, assistant, what the answer said, verdict, what the source says, source and date

    4rows

    Download checks against official sources (CSV)

  • Recommendation coding

    recommendation-coding.csv

    One row per coded national loan-choice or support answer.

    Answer ID, question ID, borrower, assistant, question group, recommended lenders and supporting passages

    360rows

    Download recommendation coding (CSV)

  • Platform comparisons

    platform-recommendation-counts.csv

    One row per platform, lender and question group.

    Matched panel, recommended answers, denominator and supporting answer IDs

    105rows

    Download platform comparisons (CSV)

  • City comparisons

    city-recommendation-counts.csv

    One row per city, lender and question group.

    Matched panel, recommended answers, denominator and supporting answer IDs

    112rows

    Download city comparisons (CSV)

Use these tables to trace findings back to the original questions and answers. The full text of each answer is also on this page, under its question.

03

Read in full and checked

Some answers were read in detail or checked against official sources. Those appear on the study page, beside the findings they support.

ChatGPT · National

We bought our first rental last year and now have two mortgages with the same bank. It's been hard to get advice on how to set the loans up. Are some banks better at supporting landlords with more than one property?

Yes — in New Zealand, some banks may be a better fit for landlords who own multiple properties, particularly when it comes to how they assess rental income, release equity, structure loans and support future purchases. But the quality of the lending advice and the way your mortgages are structured can matter just as much as which bank you use.

Since you've already bought your first rental and have two mortgages with the same bank, I'd focus on two things: whether your current loans are set up well for your long-term plans, and whether another lender could offer more flexibility.

What makes a bank good for property investors?

These are the main differences I'd look at when comparing New Zealand lenders.

  • Portfolio lending: How well the bank assesses your overall financial position across your home and rental property, rather than treating every new purchase as an isolated application.
  • Equity access: How straightforward it is to use available equity towards another deposit, subject to lending criteria.
  • Loan structure: Whether you can keep lending for each property separately, rather than unnecessarily tying multiple properties together as security.
  • Rental income assessment: How much of your rental income the bank recognises when calculating what you can afford to borrow.
  • Repayment flexibility: Whether it offers suitable fixed-term splits, revolving-credit facilities or interest-only periods, where appropriate.
  • Relationship management: Whether you can get advice from someone who understands investment lending and can plan with you beyond your next mortgage refix.

For example, ANZ's published investment-property guidance discusses using equity across multiple properties, subject to its lending criteria. Westpac also has specific investment-property lending policies. These are useful starting points, but they don't establish that either bank is best for every landlord. Borrowing for an investment propertyWestpac Mortgage Advisers

Which New Zealand banks should you compare?

I'd start by asking for a comparison across these lenders rather than assuming you need to move.

ANZ New Zealand

A useful starting point if you want to understand how equity across your home and rental could support future borrowing. Its published guidance specifically discusses combining equity across properties. Borrowing for an investment property

Read: ANZ investment property borrowing

Westpac New Zealand

Worth including in a comparison of investment-specific lending rules, including how rental income and repayment options are assessed. Confirm its current criteria for your circumstances.

Read: Westpac New Zealand

BNZ

Ask for an assessment of your combined household and rental-property finances, and whether its lending structure would give you better flexibility for another purchase.

Read: BNZ home loans

Kiwibank

Another lender to benchmark against your current bank on rates, equity requirements, loan splits and the treatment of rental income.

Read: Kiwibank home loans

These are lenders to compare, not a ranking of which bank is best for landlords. Their suitability depends on your equity, income, existing debt and plans.

One thing I'd investigate before switching banks

Check whether your two properties are cross-collateralised.

This means the bank uses both properties as security for your borrowing, rather than keeping the security arrangements separate.

  • Linked securities: Can make the overall lending arrangement convenient, but selling one property or moving one loan may require the bank to reassess the wider arrangement.
  • Separate securities: May give you more flexibility to refinance or sell one property independently, although the bank still assesses your overall ability to repay.

You can ask your current bank whether each property can support its own loan facilities and what would be required to release either property from its security.

Also, avoid switching just for a slightly lower interest rate without checking any cashback repayment obligations, break fees and legal or valuation costs.

Don't overlook New Zealand's lending rules

As at October 2026, Reserve Bank restrictions remain relevant when you want to expand a rental portfolio:

  • Loan-to-value ratios (LVRs): Banks can generally lend up to 70% of an investment property's value under the standard investor threshold, with limited allowances for higher-LVR lending.
  • Debt-to-income ratios (DTIs): Investor borrowing above seven times gross annual income is considered high-DTI lending. Banks can make a limited proportion of new loans above that threshold.

These are limits on banks' lending, not guarantees that you'll qualify to borrow up to those levels. Banks also apply their own affordability assessments. Loan-to-value ratio restrictions - Reserve Bank of New ZealandUnderstanding debt-to-income (DTI) restrictions - Reserve Bank of New ZealandReserve Bank maintains Loan-to-Value Ratio (LVR) settings - Reserve Bank of New Zealand

Official guidance: Reserve Bank — LVR restrictions and DTI restrictions.

My recommendation: find a mortgage adviser who specialises in property investors

Rather than relying solely on your bank's lending manager, consider a mortgage adviser who regularly works with landlords building a portfolio. Ask them to compare several lenders and provide a written explanation of the recommended structure, including its trade-offs.

The New Zealand Financial Markets Authority recommends asking advisers which lenders they cover, how they're paid, why they recommend a particular loan and what fees or early-exit costs may apply. Mortgage adviceWorking with a financial adviser

You can use the FMA's mortgage advice guide to help assess an adviser.

Can I narrow this down for you?

One question first: are you hoping to buy another rental property in the next few years, or are you mainly wanting to get your existing two mortgages structured properly?

That makes a difference to whether I'd focus on future borrowing capacity, loan flexibility, or simply improving the arrangement you already have.

Ask anything

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

Captured 11 October 2026

Gemini · National

We bought our first rental last year and now have two mortgages with the same bank. It's been hard to get advice on how to set the loans up. Are some banks better at supporting landlords with more than one property?

Managing a growing property portfolio introduces a layer of complexity that standard retail banking isn't always naturally set up to handle, which is why getting clear answers can be so frustrating.

When you have multiple mortgages with the same bank, you run into specific operational challenges—most notably cross-collateralisation (where the bank ties your properties together) and how the bank assesses your rental income (often called rental shading).

Do some banks handle property investors better?

In New Zealand, the major retail banks (ANZ, ASB, BNZ, Kiwibank, and Westpac) all have dedicated mobile mortgage managers or commercial/property investor divisions, but their internal policies differ significantly in ways that affect landlords:

  • Rental Income Shading: When calculating your borrowing power for your next purchase, banks don't just take 100% of your rental income. They apply a "shading" percentage to account for vacancies, maintenance, and insurance (often counting only 65% to 80% of the rent). Some lenders are more conservative than others here, which heavily impacts your future borrowing capacity.
  • Structuring and Flexibility: Some banks make it far easier to split a portfolio into multiple tranches (fixed portions, revolving credit, or offset facilities) without forcing everything under a single blanket mortgage.
  • The "Single Bank" Trap: Keeping everything with one bank is common for your first few properties because it simplifies administration. However, as you scale, a single bank holds security over all your properties. If you want to sell one or shift strategy, that bank has total control over the sale proceeds and how they are distributed. Many experienced investors eventually use a "split banking" strategy (spreading loans across different lenders once they have enough equity) to maintain flexibility.

How to structure multiple loans with your current setup

Since you already have two mortgages with the same bank, protecting your flexibility and optimizing for tax (especially with New Zealand's interest deductibility rules) requires a deliberate structure:

  1. Keep Your Debts Clearly Separated: Never mix personal debt (like your owner-occupier home mortgage) with investment debt. Each property should have its own distinct loan sub-account.
  2. Utilize Revolving Credit or Offset for Cash Flow: If you have cash buffers or savings generated from your rental income or personal salary, park them in an offset or revolving credit facility attached strictly to your personal home loan, rather than the investment property. This minimizes non-deductible debt faster while keeping your investment debt cleanly separated for your accountant.
  3. Align with Your Accountant: Your loan structure must mirror your tax strategy. Because residential investment interest deductibility rules require precise tracking, your mortgage structure needs to clearly isolate the interest attributed to income-generating assets.

Recommended Action Plan

To get past the roadblock of getting inconsistent advice from your current bank branch, take these concrete steps:

  1. Request a Portfolio Review Meeting: Ask your current bank for an appointment specifically with a mobile mortgage manager or a specialist investor banker, rather than a general customer service representative at a local branch.
  2. Consult an Independent Mortgage Adviser: Mortgage brokers/advisers in New Zealand who specialize in property investment are usually free for you to use (as the banks pay them commission). They have a macro view of how all the major New Zealand banks view rental shading, equity release, and structuring at the moment.
  3. Map Out Your Next 3-Year Goal: Bring a clear outline of your goals to your adviser or banker (e.g., "We want to buy one more property in 3 years"). This forces them to look at your structure through a growth lens rather than just treating your current two loans as isolated accounts.

Are you primarily trying to figure out how to structure these current loans to free up equity for a future purchase, or are you looking to lower your overall monthly repayments?

Ask Gemini

Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

Captured 11 October 2026

Google AI Mode · National

We bought our first rental last year and now have two mortgages with the same bank. It's been hard to get advice on how to set the loans up. Are some banks better at supporting landlords with more than one property?

In New Zealand , there isn't necessarily one single "best" bank for property investors; instead, the real risk to your growth and financial flexibility is keeping all your loans tied to one institution.

By having your owner-occupied home loan and your rental mortgage with the same bank, your loans are almost certainly cross-collateralised (or cross-securitised) under an umbrella security. This means the bank views both properties as a single pool of collateral to secure the total debt.

The Danger of the "One Bank" Approach

  • Loss of Control on Sale: If you decide to sell the rental property, the bank can legally demand that 100% of the sale proceeds go toward paying down your owner-occupied mortgage, rather than letting you keep the cash profit.
  • Trapped Equity: If the property market dips slightly or the Reserve Bank shifts Loan-to-Value Ratio (LVR) restrictions, your primary bank will re-evaluate your entire portfolio during any new application, potentially freezing your ability to borrow further against your own home.
  • Strict Servicing Policies: Each bank has different "test rates" (how they stress-test your ability to pay) and different shaded percentages for rental income (e.g., only counting 75%–80% of rent toward your income). If your bank has conservative rules, your borrowing capacity is instantly throttled.

The Solution: The Split Banking Strategy

Sophisticated property investors in NZ use a method called Split Banking. Instead of using one bank for everything, you distribute your security.

Feature Using One Bank (Your Current Setup) Split Banking (Recommended Setup)
Security Link Cross-collateralised. Your home secures the rental, and the rental secures your home. Ring-fenced. Each property stands entirely on its own with separate lenders.
Sale of Rental Bank dictates where the cash goes and may force home debt reduction. You keep the net profit after clearing that specific property's mortgage.
Borrowing Power Throttled by a single bank's credit and LVR limits across your total wealth. Optimised. Bank A only looks at your home; Bank B only looks at the investment.

How to Correctly Set Up Your Loans

To untangle your current setup and structure your loans for the future, follow this typical operational blueprint:

  1. Establish a Clean Deposit Facility (Bank A): Keep your owner-occupied home loan with your current bank (Bank A). If you need a deposit for a future property, top up your mortgage at Bank A as a separate revolving credit or floating facility. This means you only borrow the 20% to 30% deposit against your home equity.
  2. Move the Main Investment Debt (Bank B): Take that deposit cash and go to a completely different bank (Bank B) to secure the remaining 70% to 80% loan against the investment property itself. Bank B has absolutely no legal claim or mortgage over your family home.
  3. Optimise Loan Types for Cashflow: For the investment loan at Bank B, consider an interest-only term (usually up to 5 years). This maximises your short-term cash flow and keeps your taxable deductions clean, while you focus any spare personal income on aggressively paying down the non-deductible debt on your family home.

Next Steps

Because breaking fixed-rate terms can trigger break fees and banks change their risk appetites frequently, do not try to negotiate this directly with the banks yourself. Your best move is to engage an independent mortgage broker (mortgage adviser). Their services are typically free to you (paid via bank commission), and they specialize in mapping out multi-bank strategies tailored to your exact income and portfolio goals.

To help point you in the right direction, could you share:

  • Are your current loans on fixed or floating interest rates?
  • Is your long-term goal to buy more rentals , or do you want to stick with just this one for now?
  • Is your current rental an existing house or a new build?

Opes Partners

The Split Banking Strategy: Improve Your Equity in…

split banking involves splitting (or spreading) your lending across multiple banks. It can protect you from banks forcing you to p...

Canstar NZ

Compare the best-rated home loans in New Zealand

Banks have to adhere to strict limits on the number of home loans they can issue to borrowers with low deposits, as these mortgage...

Craig Pope Financial

6 key things borrowers forget when managing their home loans.

When you sell, you will not automatically be able to hold back $300k in cash, unless already negotiated with the bank.

Ask anything

Captured 11 October 2026

AI Overviews · National

We bought our first rental last year and now have two mortgages with the same bank. It's been hard to get advice on how to set the loans up. Are some banks better at supporting landlords with more than one property?

AI Overview

No single New Zealand bank is universally "better" for property investors, but how they differ comes down to two major hurdles you are likely facing: their strictness with servicing (affordability) rules and their automatic tendency to "cross-collateralise" your properties.

If you deal directly with a standard retail bank branch, they often structure your loans in a way that protects the bank, rather than optimizing your flexibility or tax position.

To navigate this successfully, you need to understand how the major New Zealand lenders treat landlords and how to set your mortgages up for the future.

How the Major NZ Banks Treat Investors

While the core interest rates among the big four remain highly competitive with one another, their underlying credit appetites vary significantly:

Lender Property Portfolio Investor Appetite Key Structural Characteristics
ANZ High / Active Known as an active portfolio lender. They often feature multi-property interest discount structures and have historically been more flexible with lower-deposit investor exceptions depending on RBNZ speed limits.
BNZ High / Structured Highly favored for their TotalMoney (revolving credit/offset) accounts, which are excellent for managing investor cash flow. Larger portfolios are often transitioned seamlessly into their Business/Commercial banking wings.
Westpac High / Volume Statistically one of the largest lenders to property investors in NZ. However, their standard policy heavily relies on cross-collateralisation unless you or an adviser explicitly negotiate standalone securities.
ASB Moderate / Standalone Tends to assess each property on a standalone basis rather than viewing the portfolio as a holistic business, which can limit borrowing caps sooner for aggressive growth.
Kiwibank Conservative Typically maintains tighter guidelines and a lower appetite for investors holding multiple residential rentals compared to the Australian-owned majors.

The Trap You Are Likely In: Cross-Collateralisation

When you have your home and your rental property with the same bank, the lender will almost always link them together so that all properties secure all loans. This is called cross-collateralisation, and it creates major friction for landlords:

  • Loss of Control Over Cash: If you decide to sell the rental property in the future, the bank has the legal right to force you to use 100% of the sale proceeds to pay down the mortgage on your personal home, rather than letting you keep the cash to reinvest.

  • Policy Red Tape: If your financial position or bank policies change, a review on one property forces a bureaucratic review of your entire portfolio.

The Recommended Setup: Split Banking

To fix this and get proper advice, most experienced New Zealand investors utilize a strategy called Split Banking.

  1. Keep Your Home Separate: Place your personal owner-occupied home with Bank A. Set up a standalone revolving credit or equity-release facility against it to act strictly as your deposit pool for investments.

  2. Move the Rental Mortgage: Place your rental property's main loan (the other 70% to 80% of the purchase value) with Bank B.

This isolates the risk. Bank B has no legal claim over your family home, and if you sell the rental, Bank B can only demand that its specific loan be paid back—leaving the remaining cash completely in your hands.

Your Next Step

Because retail bank staff are trained to sell their own products rather than give holistic structural advice, you should speak to an independent mortgage broker (adviser) who specializes in property investment. They can look at your current two mortgages, calculate your borrowing capacity across different bank test-rates, and safely untangle your loans into a scalable, split-banking structure without triggering unnecessary costs.

Ask anything

Captured 11 October 2026