Evidence · Home lending

The questions and original answers

Explore every question and captured response in the home-lending study, including answers asked nationally and from four cities.

questions
193
captured answers
1,094
AI platforms
4
collected
11 October 2026

01

Every question, with its answers

Each question was written as a voter would ask it and went to all four assistants. Some were also asked from a town. Open a question to read every answer to it in full.

Showing 20 of 193 questions

02

The tables behind the study

Every figure on the study page comes from these tables. They are CSV files, which open in any spreadsheet.

  • Question catalogue

    questions.csv

    One row per question.

    Question ID, borrower, exact question, group and collected answers

  • Answers

    answers.csv

    One row per answer, with its full text.

    Answer ID, question ID, borrower, assistant, city, words, coded recommendations, showed a link and full text

  • Sources by answer

    sources.csv

    One row for each website recorded as a source of an answer.

    Answer ID, question ID, assistant, city, website and publisher type

  • Checks against official sources

    checks.csv

    One row per statement checked.

    Check, answer ID, assistant, what the answer said, verdict, what the source says, source and date

  • Recommendation coding

    recommendation-coding.csv

    One row per coded national loan-choice or support answer.

    Answer ID, question ID, borrower, assistant, question group, recommended lenders and supporting passages

  • Platform comparisons

    platform-recommendation-counts.csv

    One row per platform, lender and question group.

    Matched panel, recommended answers, denominator and supporting answer IDs

  • City comparisons

    city-recommendation-counts.csv

    One row per city, lender and question group.

    Matched panel, recommended answers, denominator and supporting answer IDs

Use these tables to trace findings back to the original questions and answers. The full text of each answer is also on this page, under its question.

03

Read in full and checked

Some answers were read in detail or checked against official sources. Those appear on the study page, beside the findings they support.

ChatGPT · National

We're a salaried couple buying our first home with about a 25% deposit and little experience with mortgages. What matters most to us is getting good help and advice when we need it. Which lenders would you recommend for our home loan, and why?

Best home loan lenders for first-home buyers in New Zealand

For a salaried couple buying your first home with a 25% deposit and a strong preference for helpful, reliable advice, I'd focus on lenders that offer a combination of good mortgage support, competitive interest rates, flexibility and clear communication.

My recommendation is to compare a few of New Zealand's major banks rather than automatically choosing the lender with the lowest advertised rate. When you're new to mortgages, having someone who explains your options, responds promptly and helps you make good decisions can be worth more than a small difference in interest rates.

Your 25% deposit is a good starting point. It means you're looking to borrow around 75% of the property's value, which generally puts you in a stronger position than buyers with smaller deposits. You may have access to a wider range of lending options, although approval will still depend on your income, expenses, existing debts and the property you're buying.

My recommended lenders

I'd start with BNZ, Westpac and ASB, then compare ANZ and Kiwibank. I'd also consider SBS Bank because it has a strong first-home-buyer offering.

This is a shortlist based on the support and guidance the lenders describe offering, rather than a definitive ranking of customer service. Individual experiences depend heavily on the mortgage specialist you get.

1. BNZ — best starting point for guided support

Why I'd shortlist it: BNZ explicitly offers first-home buyers a dedicated home loan specialist to support them from searching for a property through to signing the purchase agreement. Its guidance also covers conditional approval, loan structures, fixed versus floating rates and early repayment charges. That's a useful combination when you're new to mortgages. bnz.co.nz, bnz.co.nz

What I like for your situation:

  • Dedicated support: You have a named specialist to help guide you through the process.
  • Educational resources: BNZ explains the different decisions you'll face rather than focusing solely on getting your application approved.
  • Potential cash contribution: BNZ advertises at least $5,000 cash back for eligible first-home buyers borrowing $250,000 or more. Check the current terms and any conditions attached to the offer. bnz.co.nz

My take: BNZ would be one of my first appointments. Ask whether your specialist will remain your main contact after settlement, when questions about repayments, refinancing and restructuring often arise.

Website: BNZ first-home buyers

2. Westpac — best for access to mortgage experts

Why I'd shortlist it: Westpac offers personalised home lending advice, with options to speak to an expert by phone, meet at a branch or arrange a meeting at a convenient location. It also offers first-home-buyer seminars covering the buying process, applications and deposits. westpac.co.nz

What I like for your situation:

  • Flexible contact: You can choose how you want to meet your mortgage specialist.
  • Guidance from the beginning: You can get advice before you've found a property, including help with conditional approval.
  • Educational support: Its first-home-buyer resources can help you understand the process before making a substantial financial commitment.
  • Potential cash contribution: Westpac advertises $5,000 or more for eligible first-home buyers taking out a new home loan of at least $250,000. Eligibility conditions apply. westpac.co.nz

My take: Westpac is particularly worth considering if you'd prefer to talk through decisions with a real person rather than work everything out through an app.

Website: Westpac first-home buyers

3. ASB — best for a structured first-home-buyer experience

Why I'd shortlist it: ASB offers access to a dedicated Home Ownership Manager who can guide buyers through the process, including deposit options and the steps involved in securing a home loan. It also offers online tools for managing your mortgage. asb.co.nz, asb.co.nz

What I like for your situation:

  • A dedicated adviser: A good fit if you want someone to explain your options and guide you through the paperwork.
  • Flexible support: ASB offers meetings with home-buying specialists at a time and place that suits you.
  • Digital tools: Useful for keeping track of your mortgage and managing your finances once you become homeowners.
  • Potential cash contribution: ASB advertises a $5,000 contribution for eligible first-home buyers taking out a qualifying home loan of at least $200,000. Conditions apply. asb.co.nz

My take: ASB deserves a place on your shortlist if you want a combination of personal guidance and convenient digital banking. Ask how readily you can contact your Home Ownership Manager when you have a question that doesn't fit neatly into the application process.

Website: ASB home loans

4. ANZ — best to consider if you value a mobile mortgage specialist

Why I'd shortlist it: ANZ offers Home Loan Coaches who can help you understand your borrowing options, plan your next steps, arrange pre-approval and estimate repayments. Its Mobile Mortgage Managers can also meet at a time and place that's convenient for you. anz.co.nz, anz.co.nz

What I like for your situation:

  • Help before you buy: You can discuss affordability and borrowing options before committing to a property.
  • Convenient appointments: A mobile specialist may suit you if you both have busy work schedules.
  • Practical guidance: The bank provides resources on deposits, KiwiSaver withdrawals and the home-buying process.

My take: ANZ is worth comparing with BNZ, Westpac and ASB. I'd pay particular attention to how much time the specialist is willing to spend explaining different mortgage structures and answering follow-up questions.

Website: ANZ first-home buyers

5. Kiwibank — best alternative if you want to consider a New Zealand-owned bank

Why I'd shortlist it: Kiwibank is worth including if you'd like to compare a New Zealand-owned bank with the larger Australian-owned banking groups. It offers home loan specialists who provide obligation-free advice and guidance throughout the home-buying process. Its published customer support hours also include weekends. kiwibank.co.nz

What I'd investigate:

  • How easily you can reach a home loan specialist when you need help.
  • Whether you'll have a consistent point of contact throughout the application.
  • How its interest rates, loan features and cash contributions compare with the other banks.
  • Whether its service model suits the way you prefer to manage your finances.

My take: Kiwibank is a sensible comparison option. I wouldn't assume it's automatically better or worse for service based on its ownership; I'd judge it on the quality of the specific adviser and the offer you receive.

Website: Kiwibank home loans and contact information

6. SBS Bank — worth checking for first-home-buyer value

Why I'd shortlist it: SBS Bank is worth considering because its first-home-buyer offering has received recognition in Canstar's award research. Canstar's 2026 comparison highlights its FirstHome Combo, which combines a discounted fixed rate with a cash contribution and other potential benefits. canstar.co.nz

What I'd investigate:

  • Whether its current first-home-buyer package is competitive for your borrowing amount.
  • What personal mortgage support you'll receive throughout the application and after settlement.
  • Whether the overall package remains attractive after considering the interest rate, fees and conditions.

My take: I'd include SBS in your rate and package comparison, but I'd want to speak to its lending team before ranking it alongside the others for personalised service.

Website: SBS Bank


Should you use a mortgage broker instead of approaching banks directly?

Given that getting good advice is your number-one priority, I'd seriously consider using an independent mortgage adviser alongside approaching one or two banks directly.

A mortgage adviser (often called a mortgage broker) can explain your options, prepare your application and compare home loans across multiple lenders. This can save you time and give you a broader view of the market.

According to Sorted's guide to shopping for a mortgage, brokers can help borrowers compare lenders and negotiate, although some banks don't work with brokers.

Here's how I'd compare the two approaches:

Factor Bank mortgage specialist Mortgage adviser/broker
Range of lenders Primarily their own bank Multiple lenders, depending on their panel
Personal guidance Can be excellent Can be excellent
Comparing mortgage offers Limited to their bank's products Can compare offers from several lenders
Negotiating rates Can negotiate within their bank's options May negotiate with lenders on your behalf
Cost to you Usually no separate advice fee for standard home lending Often paid by lender commission, but fees can apply
Independence Represents their bank's lending options Can offer broader comparisons, but may have commercial incentives

The quality of advice depends on the individual, not just the business model.

What I'd look for in a mortgage adviser

I'd prioritise someone who:

  • Has extensive experience helping first-home buyers.
  • Explains mortgage terminology in plain English without pressuring you.
  • Compares at least several mainstream lenders, including the banks listed above.
  • Explains why they're recommending a particular loan structure, not just a particular bank.
  • Is transparent about commissions, fees and which lenders they can access.
  • Remains available to help when your fixed interest rate expires or your circumstances change.

Check that the adviser operates under a licensed financial advice provider and is appropriately registered. You can start with Sorted's guide to finding financial advice.

One important caveat: a broker doesn't necessarily cover every lender, and a bank may sometimes offer a better deal directly. I'd use the broker's recommendation as a comparison point rather than automatically accepting it.

What matters most with your 25% deposit?

With your deposit, I'd focus on four things when comparing offers.

1. The quality of the advice

This should be your primary consideration.

Ask each lender how you'll be supported through:

  • Pre-approval and working out your realistic budget.
  • Making an offer and meeting the bank's lending conditions.
  • Choosing between fixed and floating interest rates.
  • Deciding whether to split the mortgage into multiple portions.
  • Managing the loan after settlement and reviewing it when your fixed term expires.

A good specialist should explain the trade-offs, help you understand the risks and give you time to make informed decisions.

2. The total cost of the mortgage

Don't compare interest rates in isolation.

Ask each lender for a written summary of:

  • The interest rates available to you.
  • Any cash contribution or cashback offer.
  • Establishment fees and other applicable charges.
  • Any conditions attached to the cash contribution, including repayment requirements if you switch banks early.
  • The flexibility to make extra repayments without incurring penalties.

Even a small interest-rate difference can matter considerably over a large mortgage. Equally, a cashback offer can look attractive but may not compensate for a less competitive interest rate over time.

You can use Sorted's mortgage guidance to help compare offers.

3. A loan structure that suits your lives

You don't have to put your entire mortgage on one fixed interest rate.

For example, you might fix most of your mortgage for repayment certainty while keeping a smaller portion floating if you want greater flexibility. Whether this is worthwhile depends on your savings, cash flow, interest-rate options and the costs involved.

Ask your adviser to explain:

  • What happens to your repayments if interest rates rise.
  • Whether you can make lump-sum repayments.
  • What fees could apply if you break a fixed-rate loan.
  • Whether an offset or revolving-credit facility would actually benefit you.

You don't need complicated mortgage features just because they're available. For first-time borrowers, a straightforward structure that's easy to understand and manage may be the better choice.

4. What happens if your circumstances change?

As a salaried couple, it's worth considering whether you could still afford the mortgage if one of you temporarily stopped working, took parental leave or experienced a loss of income.

Ask the lender to show you how your repayments would look under different interest-rate scenarios. Make sure your budget also allows for rates, insurance, maintenance and unexpected household expenses.

New Zealand's Consumer Protection guidance on mortgages explains your rights and the issues to consider when choosing a loan.

My suggested plan for you

Here's the approach I'd take in your position:

  1. Speak with a well-reviewed mortgage adviser who regularly works with first-home buyers. Ask them to explain the process and which lenders they cover before committing to work with them.
  2. Arrange initial conversations with BNZ and Westpac, then ASB. These would be my starting shortlist because all three explicitly offer structured support for first-home buyers.
  3. Include ANZ and Kiwibank in the comparison, particularly if either offers a more responsive specialist or a better overall deal.
  4. Get written loan proposals and compare the interest rates, fees, cashback conditions, repayment flexibility and proposed loan structure.
  5. Choose the lender based on the complete package, including how confident you feel about getting help when you need it.

I'd pay attention to how each adviser treats you during the initial meeting. Do they listen to your questions? Explain unfamiliar terms? Respond promptly? Those are useful early indicators of the working relationship you're likely to have.

One final point: the banks' advertised first-home-buyer benefits can change, and eligibility conditions apply. Treat cashback amounts as offers to verify rather than guaranteed savings.


Two questions that would help me narrow this down

1. How would you prefer to get mortgage advice?

  • A. A dedicated person we can call or email whenever we have questions.
  • B. Face-to-face meetings where someone explains everything carefully.
  • C. A good adviser who handles the paperwork and compares the banks for us.
  • D. A combination of these.

2. Do you currently bank with one of New Zealand's major banks? If so, which one—ANZ, ASB, BNZ, Westpac, Kiwibank or another provider?

With those two answers, I can narrow the shortlist to the two or three lenders I'd approach first for your circumstances, rather than simply listing the main banks.

Ask anything

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

Captured 11 October 2026

Gemini · National

We're a salaried couple buying our first home with about a 25% deposit and little experience with mortgages. What matters most to us is getting good help and advice when we need it. Which lenders would you recommend for our home loan, and why?

As a salaried couple with a strong 25% deposit, you are in a fantastic position for your first home purchase in New Zealand. Having a 25% deposit means you sit comfortably above the standard 20% Reserve Bank LVR (loan-to-value ratio) restrictions, bypassing Low Equity Margins (LEM) or Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI) entirely.

Because your priority is getting good help and guidance, the right "lender" for you isn’t necessarily just a single bank—it involves choosing between dedicated relationship-focused banks and independent mortgage advisers.


Alternative Paths for Guidance and Support

1. Independent Mortgage Advisers (The Best Route for Hands-On Guidance)

  • What they do: An independent mortgage adviser (broker) acts as your personal project manager and educator. They have panels of 20+ lenders (including major banks, second-tier lenders, and non-bank institutions).
  • Why it fits your needs: Because you have little mortgage experience, a good adviser explains the jargon, handles all the bank negotiations, maps out your structure (e.g., splitting your loan across fixed terms), and does the heavy lifting with paperwork.
  • Cost: Generally free to you as the borrower, as the adviser is paid a commission by the lender you ultimately choose.

2. Relationship-Focused Banks

If you prefer dealing directly with a high street bank rather than an adviser, certain institutions stand out for first-home buyer support, dedicated mobile mortgage managers, and dedicated onboarding hubs:

  • The Co-operative Bank: Frequently recognized for customer-first service models, they feature a dedicated "First Home Buyer Hub" and specialized home loan teams designed to walk inexperienced buyers step-by-step through pre-approvals, conditional offers, and settlement.
  • SBS Bank (Southland Building Society): Highly rated for customer satisfaction and recognized in industry awards (such as Canstar’s First Home Buyer awards) for offering personalized support, educational guidance, and competitive structures for buyers stepping onto the property ladder.
  • BNZ and Kiwibank: Both major New Zealand-owned options that offer robust digital tools alongside extensive networks of mobile mortgage managers who will meet you out of office hours to talk through the mechanics of your first loan.

Key Questions to Ask Lenders or Advisers

When you sit down for your first consultation, use these points to vet how much support they will actually give you:

  • "Will I have a single dedicated point of contact?" (Crucial so you aren't bounced between a call center and different processors).
  • "How do you structure home loans for first-time buyers?" (Look for guidance on splitting your loan into tranches—such as fixing a portion for 1 year and a portion for 2 years—to manage interest rate risk).
  • "Can you help us coordinate our KiwiSaver first-home withdrawals and First Home Grants (if eligible)?" (Even with a 25% deposit, leveraging your KiwiSaver correctly is essential).

Recommended Next Steps

  1. Book a introductory chat with an independent mortgage adviser (such as a reputable local firm via Mortgage Lab or AdviceFirst) to compare how multiple banks view your combined salary and deposit.
  2. Alternatively, reach out directly to a dedicated mobile mortgage manager at a customer-centric bank like The Co-operative Bank or SBS Bank.
  3. Get a Mortgage Pre-Approval in place before heading out to open homes so you know your exact borrowing ceiling.

Would you like to explore how to structure your 25% deposit alongside your KiwiSaver withdrawals to optimize your initial offer?

Ask Gemini

Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

Captured 11 October 2026

Google AI Mode · National

We're a salaried couple buying our first home with about a 25% deposit and little experience with mortgages. What matters most to us is getting good help and advice when we need it. Which lenders would you recommend for our home loan, and why?

When good help, guidance, and hand-holding matter most to you as first-home buyers with a healthy 25% deposit, your choice isn't just about a single retail bank—it is about deciding whether to work directly with a customer-centric lender or through a specialized mortgage adviser.

Because you have a strong 25% deposit, you are in a great negotiating position and will easily clear standard equity hurdles. Here is a breakdown of the best pathways and lenders in New Zealand tailored to high service expectations.


Option 1: Use a Free Mortgage Adviser (Broker)

For first-timers who want comprehensive, personalized guidance, starting with an independent adviser is often the gold standard. They do not charge you a fee (they are paid commission by the lender upon settlement) and they act as your personal project manager through KiwiSaver withdrawals, First Home Grant rules (if applicable), and bank negotiations.

  • Squirrel: Highly regarded for first-home buyers. They provide robust educational resources, handle all the legwork of dealing with multiple banks simultaneously, and assist heavily with structuring your mortgage properly from day one. You can look into their process via the Squirrel First Home Buyers Guide.

  • The Mortgage Lab: Known across New Zealand for focusing heavily on first-home education and stress-free, step-by-step guidance. They specialize in explaining the trade-offs between different bank policies, fixed vs. floating rates, and managing approvals. You can review their approach on The Mortgage Lab.

  • Loan Market: One of the largest networks of independent advisers in the country, giving you access to a local specialist who understands regional property nuances alongside the major and non-bank lending criteria.


Option 2: Smaller, Highly Rated Retail Lenders

If you prefer dealing directly with a financial institution rather than a broker, customer satisfaction data consistently shows that smaller, locally operated or co-operative institutions outperform the major four Australian-owned banks (ANZ, ASB, BNZ, Westpac) when it comes to personalized service and support.

  • The Co-operative Bank: Regularly wins Consumer NZ People's Choice Awards for banking satisfaction because of its high scores across customer communication, service responsiveness, and fair value. As a co-operative, profits are shared or reinvested into better service quality for members. [Facebook·Consumer NZ]

  • SBS Bank: Awarded Canstar's Bank of the Year First Home Buyer Award , SBS is a building society deeply accustomed to walking first-home buyers through the ropes with dedicated, human-centred lending specialists rather than automated call centres.


Why This Combination Works For You

  • With a 25% deposit: You avoid Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI) or low-equity margins, meaning every bank will aggressively compete for your business with cashback offers or special discounted interest rates.

  • Service vs. Product: Major banks (like ANZ or ASB) have great digital apps, but their service during the approval process can feel rigid or bureaucratic. Smaller institutions or mortgage advisers trade heavily on holding your hand and explaining the process in plain human language.

To help narrow this down:

  • Do you prefer dealing with a single dedicated person who compares all banks for you (an adviser), or would you rather walk directly into a specific bank?
  • Are you looking to utilize KiwiSaver withdrawals as part of your deposit breakdown?
Ask anything

Captured 11 October 2026

AI Overviews · National

We're a salaried couple buying our first home with about a 25% deposit and little experience with mortgages. What matters most to us is getting good help and advice when we need it. Which lenders would you recommend for our home loan, and why?

AI Overview

For a first-home buyer couple seeking guidance and advice, working with a reputable, free mortgage broker (financial adviser) is highly recommended over choosing a single bank directly.

Since you have a strong 25% deposit (meaning you bypass low-deposit restrictions and qualify for the best interest rates), your main hurdle is lack of experience. Under the Financial Markets Conduct Act, independent mortgage advisers in New Zealand are legally required to act in your best interest. Conversely, a bank's internal staff or mobile mortgage managers are incentivized to sell only their own products.

However, if you prefer to deal with a specific bank directly, several New Zealand lenders are highly recognized for their dedicated first-home buyer support and customer service.

Top Recommended Lenders for Advice & Support

Lender Service Highlights & Strengths Why It Fits Your Situation
An Independent Mortgage Broker (e.g.,Squirrel, Total Mortgages, Simpler) • Compares 20+ banks and lenders simultaneously
• Handles all application paperwork and negotiations
• Educates you on structuring your loan (fixing vs. floating) Best overall for guidance. They hold your hand through the entire journey, answer "silly questions," and coordinate with your lawyer—all at no cost to you.
Bank of New Zealand (BNZ) • Winner of Canstar's Bank of the Year for Home Loans
• Ranked highly for home loan customer satisfaction
• Exceptional digital app features for self-managing loan splits Best major bank for clarity. BNZ focuses heavily on making the home loan journey transparent, simple, and easy to understand for beginners.
SBS Bank (Southland Building Society) • Winner of Canstar's Bank of the Year for First Home Buyers
• Member-owned building society rather than a corporate bank
• Offers specific bundled incentives like the "FirstHome Combo" Best for personalized care. Because they are member-owned, their staff prioritize long-term customer relationships and patient, human-centric advice.
Kiwibank • 100% New Zealand-owned bank
• Tailored first-home frameworks and highly competitive short-term fixed rates
• Clear guidance on utilizing KiwiSaver first-home withdrawals Best for local, community-focused service. They provide straightforward educational resources designed specifically for the Kiwi property market.

Why a Mortgage Broker is Most Valuable for Beginners

  1. They Speak "Plain English": The home loan process involves complex jargon (LVR, DTI, cashbacks, break fees). A broker's job is to demystify these concepts so you feel confident in your choices.

  2. They Customize Your Loan Structure: Instead of just putting your entire loan on a single fixed rate, a broker will show you how to split your mortgage into different fixed and floating terms. This protects you against interest rate fluctuations and aligns with your salaried income.

  3. They Maximize Your Cashbacks: Banks frequently offer thousands of dollars in "cashback" incentives to attract first-home buyers. Brokers understand the current competitive landscape and will negotiate the absolute highest cashback package on your behalf.

  4. It Costs You Nothing: In New Zealand, mortgage brokers are paid via commissions directly from the bank that wins your business. Because bank commissions are largely standardized across the industry, an adviser's priority remains securing the best deal for you.

Next Steps for Your Journey

To make the best progress, it would be useful to map out your timeline. If you would like to narrow this down, let me know:

  • Have you already looked into your KiwiSaver first-home withdrawal balances?

  • Do you prefer to do things completely digitally , or do you value in-person meetings?

  • What price range are you considering for your first home?

I can guide you on what documents you will need to gather for your first advice session.

Ask anything

Captured 11 October 2026