Evidence · NZ Election 2026 · Edition 2

Every question, every answer, every source

All 174 questions and the 793 answers produced on 12 October 2026. The 27 remaining cells produced no AI Overview.

questions
174
answers saved
793
collected
12 Oct 2026

01

Every question, with its answers

Each question was written as a voter would ask it and went to all four assistants. Some were also asked from a town. Open a question to read every answer to it in full.

Showing 20 of 174 questions

02

The tables behind the study

Every figure on the study page comes from these tables. They are CSV files, which open in any spreadsheet.

  • Questions

    nz-election-2026-questions.csv

    One row per unchanged question.

    id, draft, text, voterCode, issue, towns

  • Answers

    nz-election-2026-answers.csv

    One row per produced answer, with its complete original text.

    result id, prompt id, draft id, scenario id, platform, region, words, parties, literal url answer, associated source answer, temporal pair, common four platforms, response text

  • Sources by answer

    nz-election-2026-sources.csv

    One row per website associated with an answer; repeated citations count once.

    answer id, question id, assistant, region, domain, publisher

  • Checks against official sources

    nz-election-2026-checks.csv

    One row per reviewed proposition, retaining both answers, extracts and the reviewed change.

    check, draft id, platform, claim, verdict, assessment, source url, source label, source date, checked date, old result id, new result id, old excerpt, new excerpt

  • Who to vote for: coding

    nz-election-2026-guidance.csv

    One row per manually reviewed guidance answer. Codes overlap; original answers supply the evidence.

    draft, assistant, q, voter, a, declined, matched, shortlist, asked, chose, extract

  • Location and national answers

    nz-election-2026-towns.csv

    One row per matched national/location pair, with both editions.

    prompt id, draft id, scenario id, issue, platform, city, edition 1 same party set, edition 1 national result, edition 1 city result, edition 2 same party set, edition 2 national result, edition 2 city result

  • Changes between editions

    nz-election-2026-comparisons.csv

    One row per identical question, assistant and location across the two collections.

    prompt id, draft id, scenario id, scenario, issue, platform, region, old result id, new result id, old words, new words, same party set, old parties, new parties, added parties, removed parties, literal same domains, literal old domains, literal new domains, literal added domains, literal removed domains, associated same domains, associated old domains, associated new domains, associated added domains, associated removed domains

  • No AI Overview produced

    nz-election-2026-coverage.csv

    One row per planned cell where no AI Overview was produced.

    prompt id, platform, region, draft id, block, scenario id, scenario, issue, priority, question, cause, availability

Use these tables to trace findings back to the original questions and answers. The full text of each answer is also on this page, under its question.

03

Read in full and checked

Some answers were read in detail or checked against official sources. Those appear on the study page, beside the findings they support.

ChatGPT · No location

I rent with my partner and work rostered hours that change from week to week. Our pay can drop unexpectedly, but rent and bills don't. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How would the parties' tax plans affect take-home pay for workers on modest incomes?

NZ election 2026: Which parties would leave modest-income workers with more money?

For your situation — renting with your partner and working rostered hours that change from week to week — I would look beyond headline tax cuts. The key questions are how much money you keep from each pay, what happens in a low-income week, and whether any extra take-home pay is enough to cover rent and bills that stay fixed.

New Zealand's general election is scheduled for 7 November 2026. The parties are offering quite different approaches: some promise to keep taxes low, while others propose bigger changes to income tax and the way wealth and property are taxed. Tax Tips: 2026 General ElectionSummary of 2026 election tax policies

The parties' main differences

National

Approach: no new taxes

National is promising no new taxes if re-elected. That offers continuity rather than a new, targeted income-tax cut. Its existing tax settings include the income-tax threshold changes introduced in 2024. A promise not to raise taxes does not, by itself, guarantee a further increase in your take-home pay. No new taxes under National, if re-elected on November 7Tax rates for individuals

Labour

Approach: targeted cost-of-living measures and tax reform

Labour proposes a capital gains tax on residential investment and commercial property, with revenue earmarked for health. Its small-business tax measures focus on business investment and cash flow rather than a broad new personal income-tax cut. Its wider cost-of-living policies, including capped public-transport fares, could still help your household budget without increasing your payslip. Tax Tips: 2026 General ElectionLabour's Fiscal Plan 2026

Green Party

Approach: a tax-free first $10,000

The Greens propose making the first $10,000 of income tax-free, alongside revised tax brackets and higher taxes on large fortunes and some large companies. For a worker on a modest income, the tax-free threshold is the most directly relevant proposal: it reduces income tax on the first dollars earned. Greens commit to tax the super-rich and large corporates fairly, cut income tax for 96%Tax Tips: 2026 General Election

Te Pāti Māori

Approach: a tax-free first $30,000

Its proposed $30,000 tax-free threshold is a substantial change for lower-paid workers. It also proposes a targeted Kai Credit for people earning $60,000 or less, intended to offset GST costs on food. The overall effect depends on the final tax rates, credit eligibility and how the policy is implemented. Tax Tips: 2026 General ElectionSummary of 2026 election tax policies

Opportunity (formerly TOP)

Approach: tax restructuring plus a Citizen's Income

Opportunity proposes a broadly universal Citizen's Income of $19,400 a year for eligible New Zealand residents aged 18 and over, alongside revised income-tax rates and a land-value tax. This could be particularly relevant when your rostered hours fall, but the actual benefit depends on the detailed eligibility rules, tax changes and interaction with other support. Tax Tips: 2026 General ElectionSummary of 2026 election tax policies

ACT

Approach: lower-tax settings and targeted reforms

ACT's announced measures focus on selected tax changes and investment settings rather than a comparable new low-income tax-free threshold. When assessing ACT, distinguish between a commitment to lower taxes generally and a specific policy that changes your own PAYE deductions. Tax Tips: 2026 General ElectionSummary of 2026 election tax policies

New Zealand First has also announced tax-related measures, including proposals concerning retirement savings. These are worth checking separately if KiwiSaver deductions are an important part of your budget. Tax Tips: 2026 General ElectionSummary of 2026 election tax policies

What could the tax-free thresholds mean for your pay?

The Green Party and Te Pāti Māori proposals are the clearest to compare directly with today's income-tax system.

The following table estimates annual income tax on a few modest incomes, before ACC levies, KiwiSaver, student-loan deductions and tax credits.

Annual gross income Current tax Greens proposal Te Pāti Māori proposal
$30,000 $4,158 $2,750 $0
$40,000 $5,908 $4,500 $1,500
$50,000 $7,658 $7,050 $3,000

Estimates calculated from current IRD tax brackets and the parties' announced proposed rates. Figures are rounded to whole dollars. They assume the proposed tax scales apply for a full year and exclude all other deductions and credits. These are proposals, not enacted tax changes. Tax rates for individualsTax Tips: 2026 General Election

For example, on a $40,000 annual income:

  • Under the current system, income tax is approximately $5,908.
  • Under the Greens' proposal, it would be approximately $4,500 — a saving of $1,408 a year.
  • Under Te Pāti Māori's proposal, it would be approximately $1,500 — a saving of $4,408 a year.

Those are meaningful differences. However, they compare income tax alone, not the complete household financial outcome. Other tax changes, credits, benefits and implementation details could affect the final result.

Why your changing roster matters

For someone whose hours and income fluctuate, I would pay particular attention to three things.

  1. Your income in a bad week

Income-tax thresholds generally operate on annual income, even though PAYE is deducted from each payday. A tax cut can improve your overall annual position, but it won't necessarily protect you from an unexpectedly small weekly pay.

  1. Support when your earnings fall

Opportunity's proposed Citizen's Income is worth examining alongside the income-tax proposals because it changes the transfer system as well as tax rates. For your circumstances, the payment's eligibility rules and reliability would matter as much as the headline amount. Tax Tips: 2026 General ElectionSummary of 2026 election tax policies

  1. Rent, food and bills

A tax cut increases the money you retain from earnings. It doesn't automatically reduce your rent or grocery costs. Te Pāti Māori's proposed Kai Credit is relevant here because it specifically targets food-related GST costs for eligible lower-income earners. Tax Tips: 2026 General ElectionSummary of 2026 election tax policies

One further detail to watch is KiwiSaver. National, Labour, ACT, Opportunity and New Zealand First have announced different changes to retirement saving. Some proposed changes could increase the amount deducted from your pay, even if your income-tax position improves. Tax Tips: 2026 General Election

How I'd compare the parties for your circumstances

  • For a direct reduction in income tax: compare the Greens' $10,000 threshold and Te Pāti Māori's $30,000 threshold, using your realistic annual earnings.
  • For support when work is unpredictable: examine Opportunity's Citizen's Income and the detailed eligibility rules for any income-support policies.
  • For continuity rather than a major tax restructure: consider National's no-new-taxes commitment, while checking whether any specific income-tax relief has actually been announced.
  • For the overall cost of living: include food, transport, health costs and any changes to retirement deductions, rather than judging solely by the tax rate.

You can also compare the published proposals in PwC's 2026 election tax policy analysis and Policy.nz's election policy guide.

Let's make this specific to your pay

I can compare the parties using your actual earnings pattern rather than assuming you work the same hours every week.

I'll use those details to estimate the effect on your take-home pay and distinguish policies that put more money in your pocket from those that may offer more support when your rostered income drops.

Ask anything

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

Captured 12 October 2026 · shown as ChatGPT gave it, not a verified account

Gemini · No location

I rent with my partner and work rostered hours that change from week to week. Our pay can drop unexpectedly, but rent and bills don't. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How would the parties' tax plans affect take-home pay for workers on modest incomes?

Navigating fluctuating rostered hours and tight household budgets makes financial predictability crucial. Ahead of the 2026 New Zealand general election, the political parties have put forward distinct visions for the tax system. For workers on modest and variable incomes, these policies approach take-home pay through very different mechanisms—ranging from tax-free thresholds and universal basic incomes to structural shifts toward wealth and capital taxes.

The major party and political bloc approaches differ significantly regarding low-to-middle income take-home pay:


1. National / ACT (Current Government Settings & "No New Taxes")

  • Impact on Take-Home Pay: Mainly status quo, with a focus on avoiding new burdens.
  • Details: National has campaigned heavily on a "no new taxes" pledge. While the government previously delivered personal income tax threshold adjustments (in 2024), their current election posture does not feature sweeping new personal income tax cuts aimed specifically at low earners. ACT similarly emphasizes fiscal restraint and opposing new taxes.
  • For variable/modest earners: Your tax brackets would remain as they are. Because your income can drop unexpectedly, existing tax brackets and welfare/Working for Families abatements apply, but you would not see immediate extra cash in hand via structural income tax overhauls from these parties.

2. New Zealand First

  • Impact on Take-Home Pay: Direct tax relief via a tax-free threshold.
  • Details: A key priority for NZ First is establishing a tax-free threshold on the first $14,000 of income (targeted for completion by April 2027). They also couple this with proposals to align minimum wage adjustments with inflation.
  • For variable/modest earners: This directly benefits lower-income earners by ensuring that everyone's first $14,000 earned is entirely tax-free, putting more money straight into your pocket regardless of how many hours you work in a given week.

3. The Green Party

  • Impact on Take-Home Pay: Progressive cuts for low-to-middle earners funded by taxing high wealth.
  • Details: The Greens propose a $10,000 tax-free personal income threshold, paired with a new top tax rate of 45% on income over $160,000. Their wider package shifts the tax burden away from wages toward a wealth tax, a capital acquisitions (inheritance) tax, and higher taxes on large corporations.
  • For variable/modest earners: Lower-income and part-time workers would pay less income tax on their initial earnings due to the tax-free bracket, offering some cushion during lower-earning weeks.

4. The Opportunity Party (TOP)

  • Impact on Take-Home Pay: A radical structural reset via a Citizen's Income.
  • Details: TOP proposes a comprehensive "Tax Reset" featuring a Citizen's Income (roughly $19,400 a year, or ~$370 a week) for eligible New Zealanders, which replaces most traditional benefits and integrates with reformed tax brackets. This is funded by shifting the tax base away from labor onto a Land Value Tax (1.75%).
  • For variable/modest earners: For households with unpredictable or modest income, a baseline Citizen's Income provides a floor—meaning your household support doesn't plummet to zero even if your rostered hours drop significantly in a given week.

5. Labour and Te Pāti Māori

  • Impact on Take-Home Pay: Targeted support and revenue shifts toward public services.
  • Details: Labour's primary tax platform centers on a targeted Capital Gains Tax (CGT) (excluding the family home) with revenue earmarked to improve primary healthcare accessibility, alongside small-business and compliance easing. Te Pāti Māori proposes a higher tax-free threshold (around $30,000) alongside wealth and land-banking taxes.
  • For variable/modest earners: While Labour does not feature broad personal income tax cuts in its core platform, its policies lean toward lowering indirect costs (like subsidized or more accessible healthcare) funded by capital taxation rather than changing your weekly PAYG income tax brackets.

Summary Considerations for Variable Wage Earners

When evaluating these options against the stress of fluctuating hours and fixed living costs (rent and bills):

  • Parties like New Zealand First and the Green Party offer immediate relief through lower-tier income tax exemptions ($14,000 and $10,000 thresholds respectively).
  • The Opportunity Party proposes a complete structural redesign (Citizen's Income) aimed at cushioning income volatility entirely.
  • National and ACT focus on broad economic stability and no new taxes, leaving current take-home tax scales intact.

To help narrow this down for your household, are you more interested in policies that provide direct weekly cash-flow relief through tax-free brackets, or broader structural changes to housing and cost-of-living support?

Ask Gemini

Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

Captured 12 October 2026 · shown as Gemini gave it, not a verified account

Google AI Mode · No location

I rent with my partner and work rostered hours that change from week to week. Our pay can drop unexpectedly, but rent and bills don't. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How would the parties' tax plans affect take-home pay for workers on modest incomes?

New Zealand's political parties propose significantly different tax and income support adjustments that directly target or impact workers on modest incomes and renters. Because your income fluctuates week-to-week while your fixed costs like rent remain steady, tax thresholds, Working for Families adjustments, and cost-of-living assistance packages shape your weekly financial safety net.

An overview of how the key parties' approaches affect take-home pay and financial stability for modest earners highlights distinct paths:

National / Coalition Government Approach

  • Tax Threshold Adjustments: Focuses on adjusting personal income tax thresholds (repeating or building upon previous threshold adjustments implemented in 2024) to reduce the tax take for low-to-middle income earners.

  • Working for Families & Support: Relies on targeted family tax credits and independent earner tax credits rather than sweeping structural tax overhauls.

  • Impact on Variable Income: Because adjustments are built into PAYE tax tables, any week you work fewer rostered hours, your lower gross pay is taxed at the lower statutory rate, but it does not provide an automatic buffer or minimum income floor during severe drops in hours.

Labour Party Approach

  • Cost-of-Living & Worker Focus: Generally emphasizes support directed at low- and middle-income workers through adjustments to tax credits, targeted support for families, and policies aimed at easing cost-of-living pressures rather than large-scale wealth taxes.

  • Impact on Variable Income: Focuses on strengthening baseline social support and public services (such as health and housing stability) to indirectly alleviate the pressure of fixed costs like rent when weekly wages drop.

Green Party Tax Plan

  • Tax-Free Threshold: Proposes a $10,000 personal income tax-free threshold , meaning the first $10,000 of any individual's income is completely untaxed.

  • Funding Mechanism: Funded by shifting the tax burden toward high-wealth individuals and large corporations via wealth taxes, higher top-bracket income taxes, and bank levies.

  • Impact on Variable Income: A tax-free threshold proportionally increases take-home pay on every dollar earned up to that threshold, offering immediate relief during lower-earning weeks.

Te Pāti Māori Tax Plan

  • Tax-Free Threshold & Rebates: Proposes a larger $30,000 tax-free threshold alongside a targeted GST rebate (the "kai credit") for individuals earning under $60,000.

  • Funding Mechanism: Financed through a progressive wealth tax starting at $2 million, increased top income tax brackets, and vacant housing/land banking taxes.

  • Impact on Variable Income: Provides substantial structural boosts to take-home pay for modest-income earners, and the targeted GST credit offers direct relief aimed at essential living costs like food.

The Opportunities Party (TOP) Tax Reset

  • Citizen’s Income: Proposes restructuring the tax-and-transfer system around a broadly universal Citizen's Income combined with a Land Value Tax.

  • Impact on Variable Income: A universal citizen’s income functions independently of fluctuating weekly rostered hours, providing a reliable baseline cash flow that helps buffer fixed expenses like rent when work hours drop unexpectedly. [PwC New Zealand]

You can review formal updates and detailed policy breakdowns as they are released via PwC Tax Policy Updates or Nexia New Zealand Election Analysis.

Ask anything

Captured 12 October 2026 · shown as Google AI Mode gave it, not a verified account

AI Overviews · No location

I rent with my partner and work rostered hours that change from week to week. Our pay can drop unexpectedly, but rent and bills don't. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How would the parties' tax plans affect take-home pay for workers on modest incomes?

AI Overview

For rostered workers on modest or variable incomes, the key factor influencing take-home pay under different tax plans is whether a party introduces a tax-free income threshold. Because your pay drops unexpectedly from week to week, a tax-free threshold protects your baseline earnings by ensuring you pay 0% tax on your first block of income, regardless of fluctuating hours.

The 2026 New Zealand general election tax proposals split broadly into three approaches:

1. Parties Proposing a Tax-Free Threshold (Highest Impact on Lower-Income Weeks)

These plans directly increase the take-home pay of modest income earners by removing tax from your initial earnings:

  • Green Party: Proposes a $10,000 tax-free threshold. All income up to $10,000 would incur zero income tax, lowering the tax burden for all low-to-middle-income earners, funded by higher taxes on corporations and the wealthy.

  • New Zealand First: Proposes an even higher $14,000 tax-free threshold. They also advocate for adjusting the remaining tax brackets for inflation to prevent "bracket creep".

  • The Opportunities Party (TOP): Proposes a structural "tax reset" featuring a $19,400 annual "citizen's income" (effectively a tax-free base), funded by a new land value tax.

2. Parties Focusing on Structural or Flat-Tax Reform

  • ACT: Opposes capital gains and wealth taxes, instead campaigning on a flatter income-tax structure alongside broad spending restraint to achieve a faster path to surplus. While they have hinted at targeted tax relief in their fiscal plan, their structural goal is keeping broad income tax rates lower and less progressive rather than creating tax-free tiers.

3. Parties Proposing "No New Personal Taxes" or Targeted Relief

  • National: Is campaigning on a "no new taxes" pledge and prefers targeted financial support for families and businesses over making broad changes to personal income tax brackets. They argue that broad income tax cuts shouldn't stretch to benefit high-earners who do not need support.

  • Labour: Is leaving personal tax settings largely unchanged. Instead of adjusting income brackets, Labour's tax plan introduces a 28% capital gains tax on commercial and residential investment properties (excluding family homes). The resulting revenue is ring-fenced specifically for health spending, such as funding three free annual doctor visits.


To explore how these fluctuating hours interact with specific party models, you can test different weekly income scenarios using the interactive YourTax NZ Election Calculator.

If you would like, tell me:

  • Your average weekly or annual income range

  • If you have any children or receive Working for Families support

I can provide a more specific breakdown of how your weekly take-home pay might change under each scenario.

Ask anything

Captured 12 October 2026 · shown as AI Overviews gave it, not a verified account