Evidence · NZ Election 2026 · Edition 8

Every question and original answer

Read the 174 questions and 789 answers recorded on 2 November 2026, with the cited websites and tables behind the findings.

questions
174
answers saved
789
collected
2 November 2026

01

Every question, with its answers

Each question was written as a voter would ask it and went to all four assistants. Some were also asked from a town. Open a question to read every answer to it in full.

Showing 20 of 174 questions

02

The tables behind the study

Every figure on the study page comes from these tables. They are CSV files, which open in any spreadsheet.

  • Questions

    questions.csv

    One row per question, with its original wording.

    id, text, reference, enabled, axes, collectionSettings

  • Complete answers

    answers.csv

    One row per saved answer, including its original text.

    id, questionId, assistant, text, collectionSetting, askedFrom, capturedOn, cellCompletedAt, parameters, scanId, textOrigin, timingOrigin

  • Answers included in each comparison

    memberships.csv

    One row per answer and comparison, showing which results were counted together.

    comparisonId, answerId, rowKey, included

  • Party names found in answers

    codings.csv

    One row per answer, party and comparison, with the recorded decision and evidence.

    comparisonId, answerId, entityId, kind, measure, counted, quote, reason, evidence

  • Statements and sentiment assessments

    claims.csv

    Saved sentiment assessments of statements about parties, with answer references and quotations from the original answers where available.

    claimId, answerId, entityId, role, tone, claimText, quote, nativeQuoteVerified, origin, quoteStart, quoteEnd

  • Original saved statement assessments

    raw-native-claims.csv

    One row per saved statement, with its original wording and party assessments. These are automated results, not independently checked facts.

    claimId, claimText, quote, stance, platform, region, promptId, brands, sources, drivers, sourceResultId

  • Original party assessments

    all-native-party-associations.csv

    All original party assessments, including subject statements and passing comparisons.

    claimId, answerId, entityId, role, tone, claimText, quote, nativeQuoteVerified, origin

  • Assessments excluded from the sentiment bars

    unanchored-subject-assessments.csv

    Original assessments without an exact supporting passage, retained for inspection.

    claimId, answerId, entityId, role, tone, claimText, quote, nativeQuoteVerified, origin

  • Sources recorded with each answer

    sources.csv

    One row per answer, listing its cited websites, visible links and whether source information was available.

    answerId, capture, domains, urls, literalUrls, origin

  • Original saved source records

    raw-native-sources.csv

    Every saved source record, distinguishing citations from other references. The source rankings count citations only.

    answerId, url, domain, metadata, domainType, citationKind

  • Answer review coverage

    report-evidence.csv

    One row per saved answer, with its recorded review coverage and evidence references.

    key, answerId, interpretation, text

  • Checks against official sources

    checks.csv

    One row per selected statement checked in an answer.

    checkId, claimToTest, category, answerId, questionId, assistant, assertionPresent, assertion, verdict, evidence, whatTheSourceSays, assessment, checkedOn, paragraphs, previousCheckId, earlierAnswerId, earlierAssertion, trajectory, propositionFamily, reviewer, review_scope, fullAnswer, answerSha256, collectionSetting, additionalSources

  • Statements selected for checking

    check-register.csv

    One row per selected check, with its reason and official source.

    checkId, claimToTest, category, whyChecked, primarySourceUrl, answerId

  • Research findings

    findings.csv

    One row per finding, with its figure and supporting records.

    id, value, denominator, statement, summary, evidence, evidenceLinks

  • What the voting-guidance answers did

    behaviour-coding.csv

    One row per guidance answer, with the recorded behaviours and supporting passages.

    edition, result_id, draft_id, platform, boundary, conditional, shortlist, elicitation, unconditional, evidence, rationale, reviewer, reviewed_on, review_scope, question_id, region, full_answer, answerId, questionId, assistant, collectionSetting, explicit_choice_boundary, conditional_party_or_bloc_alignment, prioritised_shortlist, elicits_additional_user_information, unconditional_single_party_vote_instruction, calibration_note

  • What changed for each voter

    case-decisions.csv

    One row per voter situation, with the earlier and later readings.

    case, headline, previous_summary, current_summary, what_changed, what_stayed, previous_excerpts, current_excerpts, previous_answer_id, previous_full_answer, current_answer_id, current_full_answer, question_id, draft_id, reviewer, reviewed_on, review_scope, scope_limit, previous_party_ids, current_party_ids, party_set_changed

  • Answers compared across editions

    pairs.csv

    One row per comparison of the same question, AI assistant and location in Editions 7 and 8.

    earlierAnswerId, answerId, questionId, assistant, collectionSetting, askedFrom

  • Checks across editions

    edition-checks.csv

    The selected checks and whether their statements appeared in each edition.

    checkId, claim, assistant, earlierAnswerId, answerId, earlierQuote, quote, trajectory, assessment, evidence

  • Party counts by edition

    party-count-tables.csv

    One row per comparison, edition, assistant and party, with its answer count and total.

    edition, panel, assistant, entityId, named, eligible, sharePct

  • Party counts by topic

    issue-tables.csv

    One row per topic and edition, counting all saved answers in that edition.

    edition, panel, assistant, issue, entityId, named, eligible, sharePct

  • Location comparisons by edition

    regional-tables.csv

    One row per national-and-location comparison and edition.

    edition, panel, assistant, collectionSetting, entityId, named, eligible, sharePct

  • Websites cited across editions

    source-reach-tables.csv

    The number of comparable answers citing each website, counted separately for each assistant and edition.

    edition, panel, assistant, domain, answersCiting, eligible, sharePct, publisherType

  • Answer length by assistant

    platform-tables.csv

    One row per comparison, edition and assistant, with the recorded answer lengths.

    edition, panel, assistant, answers, anyParliamentaryNamed, allSixParliamentaryNamed, someParliamentaryOmitted, omissionSharePct, allSevenNamed, noTrackedPartyNamed, meanDisplayedPartyCount, partyCounts

  • Changes between repeated answers

    pair-metrics.csv

    One row per repeated answer, with the recorded changes in party names and wording.

    assistant, pairs, changedDisplayedPartySet, changedTrackedPartySet, changedSharePct, movements

  • Location comparison totals

    location-summary.csv

    Counts for the nationwide and local answers available on each date.

    edition, collectionSetting, pairs, changedDisplayedPartySet, sharePct

  • Location comparisons across editions

    location-pairs.csv

    The nationwide and local answer comparisons recorded on each date.

    edition, questionId, assistant, collectionSetting, nationalAnswerId, localAnswerId, nationalParties, localParties, addedLocally, absentLocally, changedDisplayedPartySet

  • Party-name context checks

    party-identity-decisions.csv

    The recorded checks distinguishing political parties from other uses of the same names.

    answerId, entityId, counted, rationale, excerpts, review_basis, reviewer, reviewed_on, full_answer, questionId, draftId, assistant, collectionSetting, reviewedOn, answer_sha256

  • Sentiment counts by party

    tone-tables.csv

    Statement assessments by party and assistant, retaining the original sentiment categories.

    edition, panel, assistant, entityId, subjectAssessments, strong_positive, positive, neutral, hedged_mixed, negative, strong_negative

  • Sources by answer

    source-associations.csv

    One row per answer and website; repeated references to the same website count once.

    answer id, question id, assistant, domain, publisher

  • National and location answers

    place-pairs.csv

    One row per complete national-and-location pair in this edition.

    question id, assistant, place, national answer id, place answer id, national entities, place entities, same entities

Use these tables to trace findings back to the original questions and answers. The full text of each answer is also on this page, under its question.

03

Read in full and checked

Some answers were read in detail or checked against official sources. Those appear on the study page, beside the findings they support.

ChatGPT · No location

I'm 18, starting an apprenticeship and living with my parents. I want to become financially independent but don't understand how voting works. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How do my two votes work, and what does voting for a smaller party actually mean?

First, it's great that you're thinking about this at 18, especially as you're starting an apprenticeship and working towards financial independence.

Here's the important thing to understand: New Zealand gives you two votes because they do two different jobs. One helps decide which person represents your local area, and the other helps decide how much power each political party gets in Parliament.

New Zealand uses a system called Mixed Member Proportional (MMP). Once you understand it, voting for a smaller party becomes much easier to understand too.

1. How your two votes work

When you vote in a New Zealand general election, you'll receive a ballot paper with two separate choices.

Vote 1

Your electorate vote

A fair and sensitive voting system – MTHWAKAZI INDEPENDENT

mthwakaziindependent.com

You choose one person to represent your local electorate (geographical area) in Parliament.

  • The candidate with the most votes wins.
  • This is called First Past the Post.
  • You are choosing a person, not necessarily a party.

Vote 2

Your party vote

What Type Of Government Does New Zealand Have? The MMP System Explained - The Aotearoa Archive

poach.wiki.ac.nz

You choose the political party you want represented in Parliament.

  • This vote determines the overall share of seats each party gets.
  • It is generally the more influential vote when deciding which parties form the government.
  • You can vote for a different party from the party your preferred local candidate belongs to.

Here's an example:

Imagine you:

  • Like the local candidate representing Party A.
  • Prefer Party B's policies on apprenticeships, wages and housing.

You can vote:

  • Electorate vote: Party A's candidate.
  • Party vote: Party B.

That's completely allowed. You don't have to vote for the same party twice.

2. What happens to your party vote?

This is where MMP gets interesting.

New Zealand Parliament normally has 120 seats. The party vote determines roughly how those seats are divided between qualifying parties.

For example, imagine the results were:

Illustrative example only — not a prediction of the 2026 election.

Example: How 120 seats could be divided

Party A

40% · 48 seats

Party B

30% · 36 seats

Party C

20% · 24 seats

Party D

10% · 12 seats

In this simplified example, the percentage of party votes translates directly into the percentage of seats.

The important thing is that your party vote isn't simply a popularity contest.

It helps determine:

  • How many MPs a party gets.
  • How much influence that party has in Parliament.
  • Which combinations of parties might be able to form a government.

3. What does voting for a smaller party actually mean?

This is probably the most important part of your question.

Under New Zealand's current MMP rules, a political party generally needs to achieve at least one of these things to enter Parliament:

  1. Receive at least 5% of the nationwide party vote.
  2. Win at least one electorate seat.

This is called the 5% threshold (with an electorate-seat exception). What is MMP?

Let's look at three examples.

Small Party A

Enters Parliament

6%

Party vote

  • Passes the 5% threshold.
  • Gets approximately 7 seats in a 120-seat Parliament.
  • Has MPs who can influence legislation and government negotiations.

Small Party B

Enters Parliament

3%

Party vote

  • Doesn't reach 5%.
  • But wins one electorate seat.
  • Can qualify for additional representation through its party list.

Small Party C

Doesn't qualify

2%

Party vote

  • Doesn't reach 5%.
  • Doesn't win an electorate seat.
  • Doesn't receive seats in Parliament.

So is voting for a small party a wasted vote?

Not necessarily.

There are two ways to look at it:

The potential benefit:

  • You support the party whose policies you actually agree with.
  • If it crosses the threshold, your vote helps it gain representation.
  • Smaller parties can have significant influence, particularly when larger parties need their support to govern.
  • You help demonstrate public support for issues that larger parties might overlook.

The potential risk:

  • If the party gets less than 5% and wins no electorate seat, it gets no representation.
  • Your party vote won't be transferred to another party.
  • If your main goal is helping a particular larger party form government, voting for a small party that fails to qualify might not achieve that goal.

One thing worth remembering: a small party doesn't necessarily need to become a major party to influence New Zealand politics. Even a handful of MPs can matter when Parliament is closely divided.

4. Why smaller parties can have a lot of power

Imagine no single party wins enough seats to govern by itself.

For example:

  • Party A wins 48 seats.
  • Party B wins 42 seats.
  • Party C wins 18 seats.
  • Party D wins 12 seats.

Party A and B might disagree on some policies. Party A could negotiate with Party C or D to get enough support to govern.

This is why smaller parties can become important.

They can negotiate for things such as:

  • More funding for apprenticeships and vocational training.
  • Changes to minimum wage policy.
  • More affordable housing.
  • Tax changes.
  • Better public transport.
  • Changes to student support.

A smaller party might only have 6 or 7 MPs but still influence policies that affect millions of people.

5. What should you consider as an apprentice?

You're starting your working life, so I'd suggest paying attention to policies that could affect your financial independence over the next five to ten years.

Here are some useful areas to compare:

Issue Questions to ask
Wages What are their plans for wages and minimum wage?
Apprenticeships Will they support apprenticeship funding and training?
Tax How much of your income will you keep?
Housing What will they do to make renting and buying more affordable?
Transport What will commuting to work cost?
Savings What are their policies on KiwiSaver?
Cost of living What will they do about everyday expenses?

Don't just look at which party promises you the most money.

Look at whether their policies are realistic, how they intend to pay for them, and whether they benefit you over the long term.

6. Important dates for the 2026 election

2026 New Zealand General Election

7 November 2026

Saturday · Election day

One important thing because you're 18: you must be enrolled to vote. You generally need to be 18 or older, be a New Zealand citizen or resident for electoral purposes, and have lived in New Zealand continuously for at least 12 months at some point.

The enrolment deadline for this election was 25 October. If you weren't enrolled by then, unfortunately you can't vote in the 2026 election. You can still enrol now for future elections. Are you eligible to enrol and vote?Enrol by 25 October

Official information: Vote NZ – Electoral Commission.

7. My advice: Don't feel pressured to vote for a big party

Here's how I'd approach your first election:

  1. Find out what the different parties actually believe.
  2. Compare their policies on employment, apprenticeships, housing and tax.
  3. Look at their track records, not just their campaign promises.
  4. Decide which party best represents your priorities.
  5. Use your electorate vote to choose the local candidate you trust to represent your area.

You don't owe a vote to any particular party. You also don't have to vote for the party your parents support.

Your vote belongs to you.

One thing I'd like to help you understand next

There's a really useful exercise we can do: compare New Zealand's political parties from the perspective of an 18-year-old starting an apprenticeship and trying to become financially independent.

We could look at how Labour, National, ACT, the Greens, New Zealand First, and smaller parties approach:

  • Your take-home pay and taxes.
  • Apprenticeship opportunities.
  • Buying your first home.
  • KiwiSaver and saving money.
  • The cost of living.

That way, instead of telling you who to vote for, I can help you understand what each party's policies would actually mean for your life.


Worked for 10s

Ask anything

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

Captured 2 November 2026 · shown as ChatGPT gave it, not a verified account

Gemini · No location

I'm 18, starting an apprenticeship and living with my parents. I want to become financially independent but don't understand how voting works. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How do my two votes work, and what does voting for a smaller party actually mean?

Stepping into voting age and aiming for financial independence is a massive milestone—congratulations on starting your apprenticeship! Gaining a handle on how politics and your finances intersect is a great way to take control of your future.

New Zealand uses a voting system called Mixed Member Proportional (MMP). Under MMP, every voter gets two distinct votes on election day: your Party Vote and your Electorate Vote.


1. How Your Two Votes Work

┌─────────────────────────┐     ┌─────────────────────────┐
│     THE PARTY VOTE      │     │    THE ELECTORATE VOTE  │
│  (The most important)   │     │ (Your local MP choice)  │
└────────────┬────────────┘     └────────────┬────────────┘
             │                               │
             ▼                               ▼
    Determines the overall           Elects the specific MP 
   balance of power in Parliament    to represent your local area

The Party Vote

  • What it does: This is your vote for a political party (e.g., Labour, National, Greens, ACT, NZ First, etc.).
  • Why it matters most: This vote determines the overall share of seats each party gets in Parliament. If a party wins 30% of the total party votes nationwide, they get roughly 30% of the seats in Parliament (around 36 out of 120 seats). This is what ultimately decides which parties form the government and who becomes Prime Minister.

The Electorate Vote

  • What it does: This is your vote for a specific local candidate running to represent the geographic area (e.g., your local electorate) where you live.
  • How it works: You are choosing the person you want to go to Parliament as your local constituency MP. The candidate who gets the most votes in your electorate wins that seat, regardless of whether they get an overall majority.

2. What Voting for a Smaller Party Actually Means

Because MMP distributes seats proportionally based on the Party Vote, smaller parties play a massive role in New Zealand politics. However, there is a catch regarding how they enter Parliament: The 5% Threshold rule.

To win seats through the party vote alone, a party generally needs to cross 5% of the total party vote nationwide (or win at least one local electorate seat).

  • If a smaller party crosses the 5% threshold: Every party vote they receive unlocks a proportional share of seats in Parliament. This gives them immense leverage. Because New Zealand rarely sees a single party win enough votes to govern alone, larger parties usually have to form coalitions or support agreements with smaller parties to govern. Voting for a smaller party that clears the threshold means giving them direct power to influence government policy, push their specific priorities (such as housing, cost of living, or apprenticeship funding), and act as a check on the major parties.
  • If a smaller party fails to reach 5% and wins no electorates: Those party votes effectively do not help that party get into Parliament. They are treated as "wasted" in the sense that they don't translate into seats, which can occasionally frustrate voters if they felt strongly about that group.

Strategic Splitting

Because you have two separate votes, you don't have to vote for the same party twice. Many voters practice "ticket splitting":

  • They might use their Party Vote for a smaller party they deeply believe in, helping that party clear the 5% threshold.
  • They might use their Electorate Vote for a candidate from a major party who has a strong chance of winning their local area, ensuring they have an accessible local MP to help with community issues.
Ask Gemini

Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

Captured 2 November 2026 · shown as Gemini gave it, not a verified account

Google AI Mode · No location

I'm 18, starting an apprenticeship and living with my parents. I want to become financially independent but don't understand how voting works. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How do my two votes work, and what does voting for a smaller party actually mean?

Congratulations on starting your apprenticeship and stepping into this next chapter of independence! Figuring out your finances is a big milestone, and understanding how your voice shapes the country through voting is just as important.

New Zealand uses a voting system called Mixed Member Proportional (MMP). Under MMP, you get two distinct votes on your ballot paper: your Party Vote and your Electorate Vote.


1. How Your Two Votes Work

  • Your Party Vote

  • What it is: This is a vote for the political party you want to see in government (e.g., Labour, National, Green, ACT, etc.).

  • What it does: This is the most powerful vote in determining the overall makeup of Parliament. The percentage of the total Party Vote a party receives decides what share of the 120 seats in Parliament they get. If a party gets 40% of the party vote, they get roughly 40% of the seats in Parliament (about 48 seats).

  • Your Electorate Vote

  • What it is: This is a vote for an individual local candidate who wants to represent the specific geographical area (e.g., your local electorate like Waimakariri, Rongotai, or Dunedin) where you live.

  • What it does: The candidate who gets the most votes in your local area wins that single seat and becomes your local Member of Parliament (MP), regardless of whether their party gets an overall majority.

You don't have to vote for the same party for both. Many people practice "split voting"—voting for a local candidate from one party they like personally, but giving their Party Vote to a completely different party.


2. What Voting for a Smaller Party Actually Means

In New Zealand's MMP system, smaller parties play a massive role, but they have to clear a specific hurdle to get into Parliament.

  • The 5% Threshold (or an Electorate Seat): To get regular seats in Parliament proportional to their vote, a party generally needs to win at least 5% of the total nationwide party vote , OR win a single electorate seat.

  • If a small party clears the 5% threshold (or wins an electorate): Every party vote they receive counts toward securing them seats in Parliament. Because major parties rarely get more than 50% of the vote on their own, these smaller parties often become "kingmakers." They enter into coalition or confidence-and-supply agreements with larger parties to help form a government. Voting for them means their specific policy priorities (like housing, trades training support, or environmental rules) get leverage in Parliament.

  • If a small party fails to reach 5% or win an electorate seat: Their party votes are effectively "wasted" in terms of seating—they don't help that party get into Parliament, and the total seats are divided up among the parties that did pass the threshold.

  • The "Wasted Vote" Fear vs. Voting Your Conscience: Some people worry that voting for a small party that might miss the 5% mark is throwing their vote away. However, many voters use their party vote to send a clear message about what issues matter to them, or to pressure larger parties to shift their policies closer to that small party's platform in future elections.

You can learn more about the mechanics directly at the Elections NZ MMP Guide. What is MMP? - Elections NZ

Ask anything

Captured 2 November 2026 · shown as Google AI Mode gave it, not a verified account

AI Overviews · No location

I'm 18, starting an apprenticeship and living with my parents. I want to become financially independent but don't understand how voting works. I am considering my vote in the 2026 New Zealand general election. How do my two votes work, and what does voting for a smaller party actually mean?

AI Overview

Congratulations on turning 18 and starting your apprenticeship! Stepping into the workforce and taking control of your financial future is an exciting milestone. Navigating your first election is a massive part of that step toward full independence.

In New Zealand, we use a voting system called Mixed Member Proportional (MMP). When you go to vote, you receive a ballot paper with two distinct choices: the Party Vote and the Electorate Vote.

Here is exactly how those two votes work and what it means to back a smaller party.


How Your Two Votes Work

Vote Type What it is Why it matters
1. The Party Vote You choose the political party you want to lead the country. This is the most important vote. It decides the total percentage of seats (out of roughly 120) that each party gets in Parliament.
2. The Electorate Vote You choose a specific person (candidate) to represent your local area. The local candidate with the most votes in your area automatically wins a seat in Parliament, regardless of how their party performs nationally.

Because you have two separate votes, you can "split" your ticket. If you like a local candidate from one party because they support your trade or community, but you prefer the overall economic policies of a completely different party, you can vote for both on the same paper.


What Voting for a Smaller Party Actually Means

Under MMP, smaller parties hold a massive amount of power. Because it is very difficult for one large party to win more than 50% of the vote on its own, big parties almost always have to team up with smaller parties to form a coalition government.

Voting for a smaller party can mean a few things:

  • The 5% Threshold: To get any seats in Parliament from the party vote, a minor party must win at least 5% of the total nationwide party vote OR win at least one local electorate seat.

  • The "Wasted Vote" Risk: If a small party gets 4.9% of the party vote and fails to win a local electorate, they get 0 seats. Those votes do not transfer to a second choice; they are discounted, which effectively boosts the seat percentage of the bigger parties that did make it in.

  • The Kingmaker Effect: If a smaller party crosses that 5% barrier or wins an electorate, they can become crucial "kingmakers". During coalition negotiations, they can force the major parties to adopt their specific policies—like changes to tax, training subsidies, or housing—in exchange for their support to form a government.


Connecting Your Vote to Your Financial Independence

As an apprentice living at home, the policies decided by these parties will directly affect your path to financial independence. When you are looking through what different parties stand for, keep an eye out for how they handle:

  1. Apprenticeship and Trade Support: Look at funding for training, tools, and workplace education.

  2. Tax Thresholds: Check how much income tax you will pay on your apprentice wages as your income grows.

  3. Cost of Living and Housing: Look at their policies regarding renting laws, first-home buyer schemes, and public transport infrastructure, which will impact your costs when you eventually move out of home.

Note: To vote in the election, make sure you are officially enrolled. You can easily check your status or update your details directly viaElections NZ.

Ask anything

Captured 2 November 2026 · shown as AI Overviews gave it, not a verified account